Card listed as a Reprint but it was Real?

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by hcv123

does that left edge toward the bottom look shiny white?

It seems to be part of what I mentioned about the bottom corners...as if they had been recently scraped (at least within the last several years or even within past decade). For whatever reason.

Brian

[TobaccoKing4]

I wonder if the seller rounded them out trying to make the card look "more real" after foolishly thinking it was a reprint.

[drcy]

Not at sales, but I've had a few items shown to me where the person assumed it was fake or reprint and it was real.

Years ago, there was a woman who had a one-of-a-kind Christy Mathewson minor league imperial cabinet card on eBay that was obviously was original, and she clearly didn't know what it was.

[toledo_mudhen]

Looks good to me - BUT at end of day it's a $35 card. Can't imagine why he would shut it down and not relist - Weird....

[steve B]

It looks like a reprint to me.

[Pat R]

The card looks fine to me.

[doug.goodman]

Assuming it's real, what would it be worth?