Would this turn you away...?

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by bnorth

I would like it better at the bottom.

I agree with that. Maybe I can crack it and move the auto down, then resubmit to PSA or something like that! Having the auto on the top isn't horrible though... a Junior auto is a Junior auto.

[AstroJake09]

I tried a few mock ups with the auto on different postcards... some of these are pretty slick.

[timzcardz]

If that was from his Gateway Major League Debut cover, all I can think is what a shame.

In my opinion that cover matted with his HOF PC would be a great combo in that it would tell a story.

As a collector, as shown above, giving consideration to how many better presented autographs are available, I find it amusing at best.

However, I respect that whoever owns an autograph (or card, etc.) can do whatever they want with it, but sometimes I just don't get it.

If someone does what they want for their personal collection I can respect that. If it brings them pleasure, who am I to question.

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by timzcardz

If that was from his Gateway Major League Debut cover, all I can think is what a shame.

In my opinion that cover matted with his HOF PC would be a great combo in that it would tell a story.

As a collector, as shown above, giving consideration to how many better presented autographs are available, I find it amusing at best.

However, I respect that whoever owns an autograph (or card, etc.) can do whatever they want with it, but sometimes I just don't get it.

If someone does what they want for their personal collection I can respect that. If it brings them pleasure, who am I to question.

It is indeed from the gateway debut cover. I'm a history major, so that part of it is special for me. That's about as rookie as you can get with Junior's auto, save for a few minor league signatures. I really have no reservations about leaving it in the case I would just want to make sure it had value should I ever need to sell it.

As for the bold quote above, and "telling a story" it really does make sense. His career started with his debut (the Gateway auto) and ended with the HoF (the postcard.) It's a piece that connects both ends of his amazing career.

I can get if for $100 even and free shipping. Is that a good deal for a Junior auto?

[timzcardz]

Personally, for that signature, I would prefer it intact on the cover and would pay the premium for the full cover.

Jr's cut signature and others can be had for less, srolling down a few on this page of sold items: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fro...&LH_Complete=1

[Frank A]

If it was me, I'd leave it alone. It's a good sig, that's all that matters. I've seen a lot of items framed much much worse. It's not that bad. Frank

[keithsky]

Personally I don't like the cuts displayed like that. Same with the Perez Steele ones. Some look like 3rd grade art projects but that's just me. I think they look better autographed on the card or if it's a HOFer that has passed then a cut outside of the card matted in a display. Everyone has there choice on what they like and that is what makes everyone's collectibles so cool. Do what makes you happy and don't let anyone change your mind.