E121 American Caramel Babe Ruth PSA A listed on ebay

[RCMcKenzie]

I showed this one to my brother. He said the Goudey's are the good ones. make an offer...

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Apparently Ebay isn't giving him the "benefit of the doubt" either since they pulled the listing...

[oceansidelivingcowboy]

Originally Posted by RCMcKenzie

I showed this one to my brother. He said the Goudey's are the good ones. make an offer...

Define good. More popular, absolutely. Outside of his rookie and near-rookie issues (Baltimore, M101/D329, 1917, 1921) they do command the higher values per grade. If your goal is to resell I'd go for one of those although they have shot up to unreasonable levels recently especially for those Auth or Poor. For me, nothing beats an actual photo of the player, regardless of rookie year or issue. I generally try to get as close to their rookie year with a real photo on the card. The cartoon drawings just don't hold the same nostalgia for me. That's why I commandeered an '07 Cobb vs his T206. Although, his T206 is so iconic I may have to get one soon enough. To each their own and good luck in the search!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by oceansidelivingcowboy

Define good. More popular, absolutely. Outside of his rookie and near-rookie issues (Baltimore, M101/D329, 1917, 1921) they do command the higher values per grade. If your goal is to resell I'd go for one of those although they have shot up to unreasonable levels recently especially for those Auth or Poor. For me, nothing beats an actual photo of the player, regardless of rookie year or issue. I generally try to get as close to their rookie year with a real photo on the card. The cartoon drawings just don't hold the same nostalgia for me. That's why I commandeered an '07 Cobb vs his T206. Although, his T206 is so iconic I may have to get one soon enough. To each their own and good luck in the search!

Of course you, my friend, are a troll who gave bad registration info. Happy collecting....

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by Leon

Of course you, my friend, are a troll who gave bad registration info. Happy collecting....

That makes sense. I read his previous comment and was trying to figure out how someone could vouch for that seller of the Ruth card. Probably the same guy.