Wheatland auction lots and psa

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by AustinMike

Larry, for your viewing pleasure.

I'd have to say PSA is consistently inconsistent.

WOW, that is crazy. This one just came back from PSA a few days ago. Compared to that one this one should have got a 10 instead of the authentic label.

[nolemmings]

Those ‘64s are just bizarre to me. All of those panels are cut to allow for the dotted line and then ample space to show–except along the top, which isn’t even close to where the lines would be. Who takes the time to accurately cut three of the four sides and then practically butchers the other one? Repeatedly?

The panels are quite crisp and worthy of higher grades, IMO, except for the obvious poor cuts along the edge. So it seems like PSA marked down for the top edge instead of adhering to its own standards, which are usually harsh and almost absolute– AUTHENTIC if not all dashed liens are present. Here it seems they were well aware that the cards were not up to spec but intentionally ignored it. Unless of course some grader actually thinks that these were designed with no dashed line across the top, in which case the incompetence is off the charts.

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

the incompetence is off the charts.

That 60 post example is nuts too.