PSA Card Case Issue? Just arrived from PSA.

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by cubman1941

Thanks - I kind of thought the same thing but ???

I can't answer this, but I'm sure someone else here can...

If Cubman (Jim) does not like the look of Tinker in the slanted + off-centered "Baggie Slab", can't he request that his card be re-holdered in the same manner as the Evers in Post 16?

At least in theory, they should be the exact same size. Does PSA have a policy on this?

[sbfinley]

Originally Posted by perezfan

At least in theory, they should be the exact same size. Does PSA have a policy on this?

Except they aren't. Slight M116 size variations are quite common from my experience. When they are slightly oversized they get the "bag" slab.

[Leon]

I prefer a baggie to a card moving around in the holder.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Leon

I prefer a baggie to a card moving around in the holder.

Same.

[aconte]

Me too. I actually like the baggie as you know the card is safe from additional
corner and edge wear from being loose in the holder.

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by aconte

Me too. I actually like the baggie as you know the card is safe from additional
corner and edge wear from being loose in the holder.

I would much prefer that they just make a Holder that’s sized right. For all the money and profits they take in, I don’t think that’s asking a whole lot. The baggies look like crap. I much prefer a clean and polished look to a diagonal and off-centered card with bunched up cellophane surrounding it.

At least they’re good at authenticating.

[thanksjoe]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Same.

I'm the same as well... seems like it works

[Batpig]

I recommend we start referring to these as “Damascus slabs”. Maybe that will make them seem less ugly.