False Babe Ruth 500th Home Run Ticket - How can PSA date this ticket??????

[hcv123]

step up to the plate ebay listings

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by hcv123

step up to the plate ebay listings

Thanks, just messaged him, maybe he can shed some light on it.

[Shoeless Moe]

So earlier I messaged him and he messaged back right away. I then asked if he got this graded by PSA, and radio silence. 8 hours later still not a peep.

His silence says a lot.

Also, if you do a deep dive into his feedback years ago left for others you will see it littered with negative comments, so another red flag. Some of the replies from the other Ebayers start to add up and give a clearer picture:

Not open to a friendly discussion about his product.....

Ticket was not as described...miscut, but described as MINT by seller

Reply by yepbg (Jul-28-05 18:28):
Irresponsible bidder used feedback extortion and attempted to bribe me to not report him to eBay for non-payment.

Reply by theoldjudge (Apr-12-06 18:10):
1st Im hearing of it. Might have achieved something by contacting me. No brains.

Reply by mrwendy28 (Oct-20-02 09:55):
card was perfect was just trying to rip me off

Poor communications, never paid me, many follow ups made with no response WHY?

Reply by 26502616@deleted (Jan-01-01 00:00):
pretty sad, I send payment $1.00 and he keeps it and the card 1 freakin dollar?

DOUBLE NEGATIVE--SIMPLY A SORE (0) EBAYER WHO DIDN'T LIKE TO BE CANCELLED-SORRY

NO communications, no follow up, poor business, KEEP THE CARD!!! NEGATIVE

Reply by 9217452@deleted (Jan-01-01 00:00):
As you can tell this person was suspened from EBAY for his illegal dealings !!!!

Reply by 9217452@deleted (Jan-01-01 00:00):
This guy had shill bids on his auction so I gave him a neutral,He's getting back


So doubtful he will reply at this point and guessing I know why. Now its possible I'm completely wrong and I will amend this if he shows me otherwise, but if I'm a buyer and see all these negatives on a sellers account, to me that's a red flag and I'd proceed with extreme caution or more then likely avoid.

But I believe another piece of the puzzle has fallen into place.

[earlywynnfan]

Any update on this? I see it's still listed for sale.