Thoughts on Montana Rookie cards?

[LACardsGuy]

where are you finding that data? The PSA auction prices site has VERY different information:

10/21/2019 $8,610.00
7/22/2019 $9,367.00
6/25/2019 $9,610.00
3/31/2019 $11,300.00
/24/2019 $10,450.00
1/31/2019 $10,115.00
1/23/2019 $10,015.00

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by LACardsGuy

where are you finding that data? The PSA auction prices site has VERY different information:

10/21/2019 $8,610.00
7/22/2019 $9,367.00
6/25/2019 $9,610.00
3/31/2019 $11,300.00
/24/2019 $10,450.00
1/31/2019 $10,115.00
1/23/2019 $10,015.00

All depends on a given site's data sources. The data provided above was VCP and other than the sale they have in common was more recent than the PSA data )the other two sales were August 2019 or later) Also even PSA's data shows a distinct downward trend on the card in general. So if you were in the market for one why would you pay even current sales prices if it's trending down? Unless you think it's hit bottom.

[mdube16]

Yes sales data is from VCP
sale dates:
10/19
9/25
8/25

[LACardsGuy]

got it. that makes sense. As for the condition of my specific 10, though, like I said, the other sellers reporting same thing.

What I was asking the forum, though, is not whether it's trending down, as that's clear. It's WHY is it trending down? What changes? Or is it just that it's uncommon enough of a sale that there is very little data, and these could be statistical blips.

[mdube16]

I would love to see a timeline from the POP report of 10s. I wonder if there is a significant increase in the past year or two.

[LACardsGuy]

believe there are 104, but no idea about a year or two ago

[Peter_Spaeth]

I am guessing some of the prices you mentioned are of the big ebay sellers. For whatever reason, the average guy just cannot get those same prices, maddening and irrational though that seems.