Ebay seller returned cracked out slab

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by wondo

I don't know that it adds any value over a raw card - but shouldn't that be for the owner to decide?

I have already stated ebay should not allow the return. I have moved on to a different angle which is whether I feel badly for the seller.

[wondo]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I have already stated ebay should not allow the return. I have moved on to a different angle which is whether I feel badly for the seller.

I don’t think that issue is black / white.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by wondo

I don’t think that issue is black / white.

Let me ask you this, John. Suppose PSA had rejected the card in the slab and the buyer returned it in the slab. Is the seller obligated to disclose that fact when he puts the card back up?

[wondo]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Let me ask you this, John. Suppose PSA had rejected the card in the slab and the buyer returned it in the slab. Is the seller obligated to disclose that fact when he puts the card back up?

In a perfect world, yes, that would be the ethical thing to do. But since the prevailing sentiment is that PSA is fallible; how pertinent is that information?

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by wondo

In a perfect world, yes, that would be the ethical thing to do. But since the prevailing sentiment is that PSA is fallible; how pertinent is that information?

I think it's still material, people can assess for themselves what it means. But without disclosure you wouldn't know.