Old Judge Baseball ??? What to do

[SCT]

I have one additional Old Judge Card which I bought, but really am unsure if it is real or not. I was told that it is definitely authentic. It has a pinhole. My question is whether you believe this is an original or not. It just seems too nice to be real. At the same time, I know with the pinhole, the grade is no more than Poor to Fair and maybe just authentic at the best. It is completely flat. I haven't seen a fake one before.



Thank You

[Fred]

If that aint real, I'm going to stop collecting OJs because if it's a fake, then someone has a great technique in making realistic fake OJs.

Just from the look of it, I'm 99.99% sure it's real.

[trdcrdkid]

That looks real to me. I’m not sure what you think is “too nice” about it, but I have raw OJs that look very similar.

[SCT]

I have bought very few raw Old Judge Cards.
Now, I am going to begin to read through the different topics of the forums to gain some more knowlege in some of these areas that I seem to be weak in.
Thank you