Old Judge Baseball ??? What to do

[swarmee]

1 Cy Sutcliffe, Clevelands,
2
3
4 ?, Philadelphias? (based on hat)
5
6 Robert Burks / Burk, Sioux Citys
7
8 Tom Daly, Chicago

Not Bat Ready, Looking at Camera as PSA claims. (Note: The Wilmot pictured is also wrong. He's batting, but listed as Bat at Side)

[Webster]

1 - Sutcliffe (447-3)
2 - Kennedy (259-4)
3 - Duffe (134-3)
4 - Robinson (390-2)
5 - Carpenter (66-2)
6 - Burkes (54-2)
7 - Treadway (463-2)
8 - Daly (114-5)

[Fred]

Good job Webster!

To answer the question about value -

Not only have the cards been trimmed, they also appear to be skinned.

If there was a really tough player (e.g. Flynn or Hahm) OR very desirable player (e.g. McPhee or Browning), then there might be a little value in there. In the shape those are in (no name, trimmed, skinned), my guess is that someone might pay about $10 a piece for those (maybe). I wouldn't pay $10 for any of them but you never know, someone might appreciate the fact that it's a 130 year old picture of a ball player.

[Fred]

Sorry Jay, I didn't think they were worth that much ($40 - $50) because of the condition and the fact they're missing the player's name.

[oldjudge]

Sutcliffe
Kennedy
Duffe
Robinson
Carpenter
Burk’s
Treadway
Daly

Probably worth $40-$50 each. Nothing scarce in there. Sorry, didn’t notice that Webster had already identified the players.