David Hall's complete t206 collection

[RedsFan1941]

nobody seems to care? what are you talking about? many many people have criticized PSA for that for years and years.

[CMIZ5290]

Yes, I agree with this. This card has been crucified for years and years. Pertaining David's collection, it is unbelievable! Also, please keep in mind, David bought a ton of SGC graded cards as well.....

[Peter_Spaeth]

Nobody who has bought it seems to care. And there is zero doubt Kendrick could sell it at a huge profit today. And I am guessing Doug's point is a broader one -- PSA started out getting one of the biggest cards in the hobby 100 percent wrong, but it hasn't impacted its business at all.

[philliesphan]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Nobody who has bought it seems to care. And there is zero doubt Kendrick could sell it at a huge profit today.

And therein lies the crux. Put aside some of the current scandals, if we take the most iconic card in the hobby, acknowledge that it is altered, and it has gone up in value by (millions) of dollars - the whole point of proceedings, particularly civil, is based upon the idea of there being "damages" that can be quantified. In the Wagner case, damages cannot be asserted

m

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Yes, I agree with this. This card has been crucified for years and years. Pertaining David's collection, it is unbelievable! Also, please keep in mind, David bought a ton of SGC graded cards as well.....

He probably didn't want all over graded altered cards.

[Gradedcardman]

David ended his quest with 5000+ different combo's.

Stop the madness and move on. The mistake was made and I am sure he answered questions on it many more times than I think about it. Shit happens. My honest opinion is just collect SGC, they are never wrong.

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by Gradedcardman

My honest opinion is just collect SGC, they are never wrong.

Hilarious, so what prompted SGC STOP their Guaranty, and not talk about it other than it being removed from their website?