FS Autograph Collection. Mostly Yankees w/ Jeter, Rivera, Mantle, DiMaggio. + Ted Wil

[Duluth Eskimo]

Let me add a second opinion. You have a lot of garbage there and by your tone you don’t seem to be concerned that you are offering forgeries for sale. Everything Chris showed you is garbage. You also shows lots of MLB holograms that are on photos. That hologram authenticates the image of the player, not the autograph on the photo. You clearly do not have a good eye for this stuff and should try to get your money back as Chris has suggested. If you think you’re going to make $5k back off of a Bucky Dent / Mike Torrez photo you’re mistaken.

[thetruthisoutthere]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

Let me add a second opinion. You have a lot of garbage there and by your tone you don’t seem to be concerned that you are offering forgeries for sale. Everything Chris showed you is garbage. You also shows lots of MLB holograms that are on photos. That hologram authenticates the image of the player, not the autograph on the photo. You clearly do not have a good eye for this stuff and should try to get your money back as Chris has suggested. If you think you’re going to make $5k back off of a Bucky Dent / Mike Torrez photo you’re mistaken.

+1

[Duluth Eskimo]

There are a number of items that have separate MLB or Steiner authentication as I scrolled to the end of the photos. Honestly I initially stopped scrolling because there was so much bad stuff that jumped out. Quite a few items in the second half look like they are probably good. I still think you’re going to be struggling to get your money back or at least an uphill journey. I wish you good luck, but you should reconsider offering this group for sale.

[brian29575]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

There are a number of items that have separate MLB or Steiner authentication as I scrolled to the end of the photos. Honestly I initially stopped scrolling because there was so much bad stuff that jumped out. Quite a few items in the second half look like they are probably good. I still think you’re going to be struggling to get your money back or at least an uphill journey. I wish you good luck, but you should reconsider offering this group for sale.

YES!! Thank you positivity

[Duluth Eskimo]

My question to you is if you know

"Some looked like it might be fake, but like I said, I knew enough was good to break even and took a gamble on the rest. I would appreciate some additional useful feedback

WHY DID YOU OFFER IT FOR SALE TO NET 54 MEMBERS prior to getting opinions or having JSA review it as you have stated. This seems to be going over your head as the comments we are making are only to prevent someone from getting bad product.

I think free opinion time is done. I'm sure JSA will be more than willing to help you sort it all out.

[brian29575]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

My question to you is if you know

"Some looked like it might be fake, but like I said, I knew enough was good to break even and took a gamble on the rest. I would appreciate some additional useful feedback

WHY DID YOU OFFER IT FOR SALE TO NET 54 MEMBERS prior to getting opinions or having JSA review it as you have stated. This seems to be going over your head as the comments we are making are only to prevent someone from getting bad product.

I think free opinion time is done. I'm sure JSA will be more than willing to help you sort it all out.

Ok didn’t know you guys would only offer so many free opinions. Maybe you should start charging. For your comment on why did I offer here thinking some might be fake? I was told by seller that they all were good and figured some would want to buy at a discount and get authentication on their own.

[thetruthisoutthere]

Originally Posted by brian29575

Ok didn’t know you guys would only offer so many free opinions. Maybe you should start charging. For your comment on why did I offer here thinking some might be fake? I was told by seller that they all were good and figured some would want to buy at a discount and get authentication on their own.

I didn't notice one "discounted" price.

The forgeries I observed, even if authentic, were not "discount" prices.

[brian29575]

Originally Posted by thetruthisoutthere

I didn't notice one "discounted" price.

The forgeries I observed, even if authentic, were not "discount" prices.

They would have been after offers made

[brian29575]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

My question to you is if you know

"Some looked like it might be fake, but like I said, I knew enough was good to break even and took a gamble on the rest. I would appreciate some additional useful feedback

WHY DID YOU OFFER IT FOR SALE TO NET 54 MEMBERS prior to getting opinions or having JSA review it as you have stated. This seems to be going over your head as the comments we are making are only to prevent someone from getting bad product.

I think free opinion time is done. I'm sure JSA will be more than willing to help you sort it all out.

It is also annoying that all you hear is negative feedback and to receive positive feedback is like pulling teeth. This is exactly why I do not collect autos unless I saw the person sign and even then I have had items not pass psa.

[brian29575]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

Let me add a second opinion. You have a lot of garbage there and by your tone you don’t seem to be concerned that you are offering forgeries for sale. Everything Chris showed you is garbage. You also shows lots of MLB holograms that are on photos. That hologram authenticates the image of the player, not the autograph on the photo. You clearly do not have a good eye for this stuff and should try to get your money back as Chris has suggested. If you think you’re going to make $5k back off of a Bucky Dent / Mike Torrez photo you’re mistaken.

Please do not attack or make smart ass comments.

I clearly stated that I do not want to sell fakes. I am not an autogrpah expert, mostly collect vintage graded baseball cards. This looked like a great deal, even with some fakes and I knew JSA was going to be in town soon. I will take the post down, but wanted to get some additional feedback that was available to educate myself and see what I was comfortable selling. In addition to what is shown, there are over 300 baseballs that are psa and jsa that I haven't listed. Several items are psa, upper deck and steiner such as:

Jeter jersey
Judge Ball
Bonds Ball
Garnett
Matsui
Montana
Harper
O'Neill

Finally I have a hard time believing all of the items that are not PSA, UD or Steiner are fake and was hoping someone could give some positive comments.