Holsum research questions

[ZachS]

Sorry I'm late to the party. I never have time to slow down anymore with the kids always involved in something (right now it's baseball... much better than soccer).

Originally Posted by rhettyeakley

Todd here are my Type 1's that have all been confirmed, I owned nearly all of them so they were mostly in my possession...

You are 100% certain of the Type 1's and 2's on your list? If so, I will update the website accordingly. I have many discrepancies when comparing my list to yours... granted I was going off what little information I could find at the time.

Type 1 differences:

-Cards on my list with a "?" as to what type (on your list as Type 1's):
Eddie Collins
Jacques Fournier

-Cards on my list as Type 1's but not on your list:
Dave Davenport
Bill Donovan (pitching)
Walter Schang
Charles Stengel
Milton Stock

-Card I have listed as Type 2 only (also listed on your list as Type 1):
J. Carlisle Smith

Type 2 differences:

-Cards I have listed only as Type 1's (Type 2's on your list):
Grover Alexander
J. Franklin Baker
Dave Bancroft
Geo. J. Burns
Owen Bush
Max Carey
Harry Covaleskie
Dave Davenport
Bill Donovan
Urban Faber
John Henry
Harry Hooper
Rogers Hornsby
James Johnston
John McGraw
Guy Morton
Steve O'Neill
Roger Peckinbaugh
Ray Schalk
Walter Schang
Milton Stock
Pep Young

-Cards on my list as "?" (you have listed as Type 2's):
Ping Bodie
Jacques Fornier
Hank Gowdy
Tom Griffith
Joe Judge
Otto Miller
W. Wambsganss - I don't have this card listed as having 2 variations w/ and w/o background

-Cards not on my list at all (you have listed as Type 2's):
Jim Bagby
Jake Daubert
Eppa Rixey, Jr.

[rhettyeakley]

Yes I am certain, I owned all but 5-6 of the Type 1’s and about 75-80% of the Type 2’s I listed up until very recently.

[ZachS]

Well alrighty then... I'll update the list on the website.