Help ID this charm picture!

[cubman1941]

I posed the same question a few years ago and the consensus was that it was Willard Marshall.

[GoldenAge50s]

Thanks Jim---that is some reinforcement of opinion!

Butch--That posting is what caused THIS thread. He won't waiver on his claim of Duke Snider, but he offers no proof. My proof that it ISN'T Duke is based on the "ear match" ID theory, but that's all I have either.

[Butch7999]

Fred, we hadn't seen the blurry-bleached-blow-up version before, so we thought
it might be relevant to the discussion.
We, too, are sure it's not Snider, but we're not at all confident it's Marshall either.
Some resemblance to both, yes, but not indisputably convincing to the six eyes here...
Can it be (has it been) determined what's on the front of his cap?

[sflayank]

not even close to willard marshall
not freddie fitzsimmons
duke snider.....yes

[nolemmings]

Delete

[GoldenAge50s]

Originally Posted by sflayank

not even close to willard marshall
not freddie fitzsimmons
duke snider.....yes

I remember you had a bunch of these charms, so what says " it's the Duke" to you??

[bigfanNY]

Looking at the picture for the first time today. First thing I notice is that player is a New York Giant. based on hat and piping on uniform. So I don't see how this could be The Duke of Flatbush..

[sflayank]

If I remember correctly its the same picture from his eureka stamp

[GoldenAge50s]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

Looking at the picture for the first time today. First thing I notice is that player is a New York Giant. based on hat and piping on uniform. So I don't see how this could be The Duke of Flatbush..

Thank You Jonathon--a couple of us were waiting for a cap ID--I never thought it was a Dodger, but didn't know what team it was!

Re: the Eureka stamp--Duke's face is much more "elongated" than the charm face--notice the distance above the eyes the eyebrows are in each pic. I agree w/ MOST everybody--it's not even close to being Snider.

C'mon Bums1953--chime in here and help out!