Grading and tilt / diamond cuts

[swarmee]

Ummm. I think that word is boldfaced in my quoted text. Yes, I agree with that.
Do you understand the difference between the two definitions of 'Miscut' that PSA uses and why the Carew doesn't deserve an MC qualifier?

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by swarmee

Do you understand the difference between the two definitions of 'Miscut' that PSA uses and why the Carew doesn't deserve an MC qualifier?

That's the difference in the two of us, John. I don't care what PSA says, you do. I don't rely on PSA's opinion, it means nothing to me. I don't care what PSA thinks my cards "might" grade. If it gives you a warm, fuzzy feeling to know that PSA thinks your card grades a (fill in the blank), then great for you. I'm not knocking you for that. Some people need that. I don't. There is a whole world of card collectors out there that don't give a CRAP about PSA or their opinion.

The Carew is miscut whether PSA wants to label it as such or not. PERIOD! Below are some raw cards that are listed as miscut (and rightfully so), but you say they're not miscut according to PSA's definition. Tell you what, you email the seller and explain to him that he's wrong, that his cards are not miscut and why. Let us know how it works out for you.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1965-Topps-...cAAOSwrYRcgCEQ

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1965-Topps-...IAAOSwlG5cgCE1

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1968-Topps-...kAAOSwYu1cgCIE

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1965-Topps-...QAAOSw4uhcgCD4

Those are all FACTORY CUTS. They are NOT TRIMMED.

[swarmee]

You obviously do care. But you keep bringing up straw men that I'm not debating you on to attempt to confuse the issue: PSA does not consider factory miscuts to be trimmed. You have said in previous posts that you expect PSA to have given those cards the MC designator. I have proven to you why they do not do that.
Hell, I have as many complaints about PSA as you do. You think I'm a homer? Read through some of my previous posts. I prefer them as a grading company to the other two, but that doesn't mean I think they walk on water.

Sorry, I'll let you get back to the bash, bash, bash, obfuscate, bash that you seem to enjoy.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Have a good evening, John