1914 Babe Ruth M. Lantern Slide ?

[Tom S.]

That picture of Ruth on the lantern slide was taken in Comiskey Park with its unmistakable arched openings behind the lower level seating.

According to Baseball-Reference.com, Boston's game on July 11, 1914 was against Cleveland at Fenway Park.

Definitely doesn't add up if you ask me...

[drcy]

Skeptical

[Fred]

Here's part of the item description:

"Other RARE BABE RUTH Red Sox Magic Lantern pieces to come....please watch my listings."

Those things are pretty hard to create find.

[TUM301]

Thanks for the responses so far guys, much appreciated. Something this unusual always makes me skeptical too and did do some of the basic research. Good feedback, he had sold the 1915 Boston team lantern the previous week, and upon request did furnish photos of other sports related M L slides. Again, thanx for your input and the continued sharing of "54" knowledge, invaluable ! Will continue to poke around but like you guys, remain skeptical.

[steve B]

I guess the question now is if it's a real lantern slide that's not attributed right, or entirely fake.

[Lorewalker]

I saw the seller's 1915 team slide from last week and while not an expert on these it did not seem as clear as I am used to seeing lantern slides. For instance compare his 1915 to the one that sold in Love of the Game...http://loveofthegameauctions.com/191...-LOT17698.aspx.

[steve B]

Interesting, there's some stuff I like about the 1915, and some stuff I really don't like.

[packs]

Image is really fuzzy. Definitely not an original print.

[TUM301]

Originally Posted by Lorewalker

I saw the seller's 1915 team slide from last week and while not an expert on these it did not seem as clear as I am used to seeing lantern slides. For instance compare his 1915 to the one that sold in Love of the Game...http://loveofthegameauctions.com/191...-LOT17698.aspx.

I hear you Chase, I also thought his 1915 slide looked less clear than the L O T G slide. The other area that turned me off with the 1914 "offering" was the hand written annotation and not the usual type on other M Lantern Slides. Would really like to add an early Ruth image, 1914-1919, but man the prices for these pieces are just going up up and away from many collectors, like me. On a side note, although far from exact science, will be on the lookout for feedback from the 1915 slide buyer. GO SOX !!