Topps League Leader - Trivia

[Gr8Beldini]

My trivia questions have been fairly well received, so I'm offering another. You wanna try Googling the answer? Good luck with that. This answer requires thinking, and maybe some looking thru your sets (which is fun, regardless of whether you come up with the answer or not...
Postwar Baseball cards (pre-1980): There have been 11 regular issue baseball cards whereby that player was also depicted on a League Leader card in the same set... with a different team. Gimme the regular issue card (player, year and team), and (of course) I'd want the team he represented on his League Leader card. Legitimately. No trick question. Go.

[jason.1969]

Man, I can't think of any!

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

Man, I can't think of any!

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

Some should be obvious (think guys traded off good seasons), others are ridiculously hard (some very obscure players have appeared on League Leader cards).

[Rich Klein]

I know one is a 1966 Leaders card of Hank Aaron listed as an Atlanta Braves and wearing a Milwaukee Braves cap. Probably others like that as well.


Rich

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

I know one is a 1966 Leaders card of Hank Aaron listed as an Atlanta Braves and wearing a Milwaukee Braves cap. Probably others like that as well.

Rich

No no no. No trick question. The leader cards in question, players are depicted with different franchises than their regular issue cards from the same set. Legitimately.

[jason.1969]

Okay, I have one. 1966 Frank Robinson.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

Okay, I have one. 1966 Frank Robinson.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

Okay a start. Probably the easiest of the 11... but once you get one, the others fall into place.

[jstef]

SB leader with the White Sox, regular card with the Orioles

But there was no SB leader card, was there?

[Cliff Bowman]

1963 Pete Runnels

[JollyElm]

It must at least partly involve the vagaries of expansion years, yes?

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

1963 Pete Runnels

Correct (that was one of the tougher ones). So far we have:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)

[stlcardsfan]

Matty or Jesus Alou? Both on '69 Hitting Leaders.

[commishbob]

Looking at one right now (I think)

Dick Stuart...65 league leader in RBI as Red Sox but he was someplace in the NL in '65. I should look it up. LOL

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by commishbob

Looking at one right now (I think)

Dick Stuart...65 league leader in RBI as Red Sox but he was someplace in the NL in '65. I should look it up. LOL

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
3) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)

[commishbob]

Catfish Hunter on '75 Wins leaders card as A...was a Yankee that year.

[nolemmings]

1971 Tony Conigliaro, from Bosox to Angels

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by commishbob

Catfish Hunter on '75 Wins leaders card as A...was a Yankee that year.

Incorrect, as Cat's 1975 card was in an A's uniform.

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

1971 Tony Conigliaro, from Bosox to Angels

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
3) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
4) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)

[nolemmings]

1964 Jim Bunning, Phils regular and Tigers LL

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

1964 Jim Bunning, Phils regular and Tigers LL

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)

[Cliff Bowman]

1978 Larry Hisle.

[jason.1969]

Am guessing this one doesn't count, but 1972 NL Pitching (Wins) leaders shows Carlton on the Cards, but he has a 1972 Topps Traded card with Phils.

[jason.1969]

This one is legit. 1977 Bill Campbell - Bosox on regular card and Twins on Leading Firemen.

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

1978 Larry Hisle.

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3)1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)
6) 1978 Hisle (Mil / Min)

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

This one is legit. 1977 Bill Campbell - Bosox on regular card and Twins on Leading Firemen.

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)
6) 1977 Bill Campbell (Bos / Min)
7) 1978 Hisle (Mil / Min)

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

Am guessing this one doesn't count, but 1972 NL Pitching (Wins) leaders shows Carlton on the Cards, but he has a 1972 Topps Traded card with Phils.

I wouldn't count traded cards as regular issue. 72 Steve Carlton, 74 Mike Marshall, and 76 Mickey Rivers are not answers in this trivia question.

[jason.1969]

In hunting for answers I found a guy where Topps used his same pic on Leaders card and regular card. That can be a side trivia question here.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Gr8Beldini

Correct. So far:
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)
6) 1977 Bill Campbell (Bos / Min)
7) 1978 Hisle (Mil / Min)

C'mon. Only 4 left, though two are ridiculously difficult; One not so hard; and one a guy mentioned above, but in a different card set.

[Cliff Bowman]

I found one that should have been but was a mistake by Topps, Dick Donovan led the AL in ERA in 1961 for the Washington Senators but on the 1962 Topps AL ERA Leaders card he is mistakenly listed as a member of Cleveland, on his regular card he is listed with the Cleveland Indians who he was traded to after the 1961 season was over.

[jason.1969]

Your hint helped a lot. Jim Bunning also in 1968. Leaders with Phils and regular with Bucs.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

[Rich Klein]

BTW -- My answer is correct -- your question specified different TEAM not different FRANCHISE. Sorry but I will play semantics on trivia questions -- having been paid on several occasions to write those and hearing all the objections

Rich

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

Your hint helped a lot. Jim Bunning also in 1968. Leaders with Phils and regular with Bucs.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-J327A using Tapatalk

Correct. Only 3 more left. So far...
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1968 Bunning (Pit / Phi)
6) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)
7) 1977 Bill Campbell (Bos / Min)
8) 1978 Hisle (Mil / Min)

Hint for the last 3: They would all fit in between #'s 6 & 7 on the above list.

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

BTW -- My answer is correct -- your question specified different TEAM not different FRANCHISE. Sorry but I will play semantics on trivia questions -- having been paid on several occasions to write those and hearing all the objections

Rich

I would argue that the Atlanta Braves and Milwaukee Braves were the same team. I understand the thought process, as many trivia questions use silly tricks that make them less trivia and more annoying. I think you understand the spirit of the question though.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Reggie maybe? Seaver?

[Cliff Bowman]

Geez, this is becoming painstaking, 1971 Bob Johnson.

[Cliff Bowman]

1972 Dave Roberts, although I believe the Padre pictured on the League Leader card is a photo of another Padre.

[Cliff Bowman]

Missed this one because I mistakenly thought he was on one of the high numbered Traded cards, 1972 Lee May.

[quitcrab]

How about a 1972 Frank Robinson as an Oriole on a leader card and as a Dodger in the traded series.

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

Geez, this is becoming painstaking, 1971 Bob Johnson.

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

1972 Dave Roberts, although I believe the Padre pictured on the League Leader card is a photo of another Padre.

Originally Posted by Cliff Bowman

Missed this one because I mistakenly thought he was on one of the high numbered Traded cards, 1972 Lee May.

That's all of them.
1) 1963 Runnels (Hou / Bos)
2) 1964 Bunning (Phi / Det)
3) 1965 D. Stuart (Phi / Bos)
4) 1966 F. Robinson (Balt / Cin)
5) 1968 Bunning (Pit / Phi)
6) 1971 T. Conigliaro (Cal / Bos)
7) 1971 Bob Johnson (Pit / KC)
8) 1972 Lee May (Hou / Cin)
9) 1972 Dave Roberts (Hou / SD)
10) 1977 Bill Campbell (Bos / Min)
11) 1978 Hisle (Mil / Min)

[Gr8Beldini]

Originally Posted by quitcrab

How about a 1972 Frank Robinson as an Oriole on a leader card and as a Dodger in the traded series.

I wasn't counting guys on traded cards - there was also 1972 Carlton, 1974 Mike Marshall & 1976 Mickey Rivers - but I'm happy to give partial credit on this one.