SGC to PSA - Crossover or crack it out and re-submit?

[Johnny630]

This is like playing a slot machine. I have a feeling people are trying get their cards in PSA holders. Sending back to SGC with their flip when they receive a lower grade, idk how they would feel. I know PSA would laugh and disregard the flip. It’s a total gamble......I wouldn’t be very happy if I was SGC knowing this is happening.

[Anish]

Always crack.

But no legit grader will re-slab a card that has been cracked. It will need to be regraded.

[silvor]

Originally Posted by Anish

But no legit grader will re-slab a card that has been cracked. It will need to be regraded.

Yup, and SGC says on their site once cracked you have to start all over again.

[52ToppsMantle]

Flipping holders seeking an instant payday is akin to daytrading and hoping you don't get burned. It is a losing game, in my opinion.

Unless you are willing to accept the risk of damage to the card from removal and a possible lower grade, you shouldn't proceed.

[Scocs]

If it’s pre-war, just keep it in its SGC holder. Enough already!