opinion on these HOFers please

[khw]

maybe its just me but the scorecard has some concerns , maybe it is the pen used or something but quite alot arent typical signatures. simmons rowe goslin and few others. i look at something like that and at any given moment a signature gets off some, on a piece with multiple signatures not a big chance they are all off , if that makes sense. not sure what pen was used , fountain pen? which isnt so common on a game signed scorecard , most are pencil , but not impossible i suppose. some pieces i just say it may be good but it may not be me , your first impression is usually on. i would be interested to see what stinson says on this one

[khw]

have never tried to upload anything i will give it a shot

[khw]

here is the other part it is a similar a 1928 score card in pencil goslin again , moe berg sam rice ray schalk bucky harris . this was just laying on my desk , but 100% real see the difference in signatures? even ina rush they still hold the same characteristics as 3x5`s gpc etc, maybe one off but common, so is the pencil

[theshleps]

Jim liked the scorecard tho was unsure on Simmons

[khw]

yeah didnt like it or goslin and all in that pen makes it all or nothing kinda for me

[theshleps]

JSA said Greenberg and Gehringer good. I have studied Greenberg autographs for sometime as I specialize in Jewish autos. I am 100% convinced on that one
http://loveofthegameauctions.com/193...-LOT13667.aspx
willing to sell for $150ppd

[khw]

yep those are the 2 i thought good well greenberg for sure but what did jsa say on the rest