The Living Hall of Fame - Just Floating a Concept

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

That leaves the decision power primarily in the hands of those who choose to cast 0s and 10s, and it wouldn't take long for the voters to realize that and for the yes/no system to be replaced, de facto, by a 0 and 10 (not 0 to 10) system.

Also why results should be public, so there's some accountability for stupid votes. Obviously it's easier to defend a binary vote "no" than it is scoring a borderline player a "1"

[jason.1969]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Also why results should be public, so there's some accountability for stupid votes. Obviously it's easier to defend a binary vote "no" than it is scoring a borderline player a "1"

I can't help but hold the conflicting views that the Hall is too bloated but I want Garvey and J.R. Richard in.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk

[MVSNYC]

Frank, not feelin' it. Sorry.

If someone is taken out, or deselected, as you say, it will ruin the idea of legacy and immortality. If a player is deselected, future generations will not know about them, thus the history and romance of the game will be lost.