Should Alabama Be Disqualified from the CFP .......

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by bravos4evr

It's gonna break down like this :

winner of Clemson and Miami- IN

winner of Wisconsin and Ohio State- In

winner of Georgia and Auburn- In

Oklahoma- IN

I mean I could see a scenario where Miami ,Ohio State and Georgia all win and Miami or Ohio State is left out for Bama... but that's probably unlikely to happen

Nick Saban said it best....it's a shame that the ONE game is gonna decide Alabama's fate......the committee has a mess on their hands.

[bravos4evr]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Nick Saban said it best....it's a shame that the ONE game is gonna decide Alabama's fate......the committee has a mess on their hands.

IMO, if you lose your division and don't even play for your conference championship you should be eliminated from consideration.


I'd prefer if they went to 8 conferences and took the conference champions into an 8 team tournament. No voting, no committee, no polls.


I mean, how could Bama argue they deserve to be there if Clemson, Ohio State , Oklahoma all win (obviously the SEC winner is going to be in) when they didn't even have to play the extra championship game?

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by bravos4evr

IMO, if you lose your division and don't even play for your conference championship you should be eliminated from consideration.


I'd prefer if they went to 8 conferences and took the conference champions into an 8 team tournament. No voting, no committee, no polls.


I mean, how could Bama argue they deserve to be there if Clemson, Ohio State , Oklahoma all win (obviously the SEC winner is going to be in) when they didn't even have to play the extra championship game?

Agreed..Alabama's loss couldn't have come at a worse time...but still....It is only ONE LOSS....to the #6 ranked team.....While Clemson lost to unranked Syracuse.

[pawpawdiv9]

It depends where they place Bama....if its ahead of UGA,,they might get in ahead of Ohio St (if they beat Wisky)
If they are placed a tad lower, might as well say bye-bye-bye Bama.

[minibatsman]

ROLE TIDE ROLE. and won it with freshman's both these teams will be in the mix for years.

[clydepepper]

Are Hawaiians even allowed to play football in the States?

-if that kid had started, it never would have gotten to overtime.

.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by clydepepper

Are Hawaiians even allowed to play football in the States?

-if that kid had started, it never would have gotten to overtime.

.

or if kicker makes short fg in regulation

[minibatsman]

I been watching Bama for years. they never have a field goal kicker. I also watch the kids at the park playing soccer in the field. not as a team with jerseys just kids playing soccer. and they can kick a ball.
there has to be a kid out there that wants a free education. or maybe Nick needs that spot for a extra line backer?.

[rainier2004]

Didn't read the thread, but F#$% Alabama...F@#$ all the way. They get free passes, officials and everything else to ensure they're great. F%$# 'em...