Babe Ruth opinions?

[Jaymz023]

Does Garo have a bad rep?

Nevermind in this-I found a good thread here all about him.

[Jaymz023]

Ok, so on the baseballs in the photos, one of them has the LOA from Garo.

[Bpm0014]

First baseball is 100% not good.

Both cuts are horrible.

I have serious doubts about the green? signed Ruth.

Would need to see the last one a little closer.

[Bpm0014]

Although it's entirely possible that the green ball WAS authentic and was subsequently traced over at some point later on... It's just a very, very, very atypical color (blue-green) for a Ruth signed ball. In addition it is also very bold for a 90 year old ball. I can see that Gehrig has signed a side panel. Would love to see a pic of that signature as well.

[David Atkatz]

IMHO the green Ruth is fine. (And part of the reason it is bold is that the ball has been coated.)

[Bpm0014]

IMHO, if real, the green Ruth is NOT a "playing days signature". In all likelihood it is from 1935-1945. More toward the latter years. A small window for Gehrig to sign as well. But not impossible....

[Jaymz023]

here is a photo of the Lou