Babe Ruth opinions?

[David Atkatz]

The two cuts are forgeries. Bad forgeries. The last two baseballs are good. The first ball is so worn that it's really impossible to tell. (But I have never seen a forgery so worn.)
And, finally, Ruth's "secretarials" are well known, and never mistaken for genuine by the experienced. It's the forgeries you should worry about.

[Jaymz023]

David, can you maybe explain why they are bad forgeries? What should I look for to help tell the difference between whats real and whats not?

[packs]

The first cut looks like it took an hour to write. It's written so deliberately and slowly. That would tip me off right away.

No comment on the second one.

[RichardSimon]

Very amateurish forgeries on the cuts.
Mr Garo and I usually have differing opinions.

[Jaymz023]

Does Garo have a bad rep?

Nevermind in this-I found a good thread here all about him.

[Jaymz023]

Ok, so on the baseballs in the photos, one of them has the LOA from Garo.

[Bpm0014]

First baseball is 100% not good.

Both cuts are horrible.

I have serious doubts about the green? signed Ruth.

Would need to see the last one a little closer.