Mickey Mantle baseball, any reason to think this is a fake?

[Sladge34]

Sorry for the poor grammar. All I wanted was people's opinions on the ball I posted, which I got. Can someone please explain why it is rude to with hold info about the ball? The original question was asking what people thought about the autograph, not anything else. Not sure what difference it makes that I had coa's?? Aren't you guys looking at only the autograph? Doesn't make sense that you guys would need to know about the coa. It's just a piece of paper. I wanted you guys to only look at the autograph, nothing else matters to me

[johnmh71]

I don't want to speak for anyone, but I think what they are getting at is that you had a coa that you felt relatively comfortable with and you presented the ball as one that you no knowledge of the authenticity. They presented their opinions under a false pretense. I can understand why some may have an issue with that. The only way a site like this works is if we act as a community.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Sladge34

Good or not

Originally Posted by Sladge34

Such as?

I haven't read this whole thread, but you asked a simple question, "Good or Not" and I believe you received your answer?

Asking for details and expecting the experts to tell you exactly what is wrong with it is another thing. No one on here likely knows you, or knows you very well, so why would they divulge information that would only assist forgers/scammers to fine tune their work?