wrong slab?

[DeanH3]

I hate the Mylar baggies as well.

One thing I don't get. If they are concerned about a card shifting, then the Mylar baggy in an over-sized holder seems like it would allow for a greater chance of shifting. I know the cards are fairly secure in the baggies, but there should still be more shifting possibility in the baggies. What am I missing?

[TanksAndSpartans]

I once sent in a card to be reholdered thinking for sure the card was in the wrong sized holder with mylar sleeve because they had run out of the correct holders on the day it was graded and this would be a chance to correct the issue. It came back the exact same way. Over sized holder, mylar sleeve. In my opinion, had I cracked out, it would have come back how I wanted because its a card from a relatively popular set and there was no issue with the size of the card.

[irv]

Originally Posted by DeanH3

I hate the Mylar baggies as well.

One thing I don't get. If they are concerned about a card shifting, then the Mylar baggy in an over-sized holder seems like it would allow for a greater chance of shifting. I know the cards are fairly secure in the baggies, but there should still be more shifting possibility in the baggies. What am I missing?

Shifting and hitting the hard plastic sides of the holder is way more likely to cause damage than the card just sliding, moving around in a plastic baggie or mylar. The plastic bag provides the cushion.

[toledo_mudhen]

We are PSA - and you are not...........