Slightly OT: Why would PSA recert a Star Basketball card

[botn]

Originally Posted by maximus35

I doubt PSA examines cards thoroughly before reholdering them. If they do it's just a quick glance. I purchased a pete rose rookie PSA 9 o/c. When I received the card the corners on the holder looked so frosted that even Tony the Tiger would be impressed. I had someone from Beckett look at it and said it was trimmed and probably had the original card cracked out and replaced with this trimmed card. I returned the card for a refund and the seller sent it into PSA and got it in a new holder.

I've sent in cards in old PSA holders I had for 10yrs I had put away. I sent a few in for reholdering service. A few looked like they may have been trimmed or should not been given the grade they received. Every one of them got a new holder with hologram. I was shocked but happy. Lol

Well yeah that too. They do not like writing checks or admitting to mistakes.