Help requested: NY Giants pennant

[ooo-ribay]

I just looked...I paid $65 for the same pennant from Bob Rothschild (anyone remember him?) in the pre-ebay, SCD days.

Chris - I think the graphics are too plain to ever be a $150 pennant.

[baseball tourist]

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay

I just looked...I paid $65 for the same pennant from Bob Rothschild (anyone remember him?) in the pre-ebay, SCD days.

Chris - I think the graphics are too plain to ever be a $150 pennant.

Thanks again. Not doubting you in the slightest. I have limited experience with pennants. Like them, but dont really follow them.

[Duluth Eskimo]

This is a nice and original pennant. Problem is it falls in to that plain era from the 40's to early 50's and there is no wow factor. I would place a retail estimate at about $100 - $125, although I think if you found it on EBay it would only sell for about $50 - 75. A lot of these plain pennant can be had fairly cheap compared to other versions from the same era. Hope that helps answer your questions

[perezfan]

Agree... Very plain graphics, and not all that rare.

Professional Dealer price = $125

Typical Ebay Seller's Buy It Now Price = $99

Actual price it would realize in traditional auction format = $70

[RedsFan1941]

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay

I just looked...I paid $65 for the same pennant from Bob Rothschild (anyone remember him?) in the pre-ebay, SCD days.

Chris - I think the graphics are too plain to ever be a $150 pennant.

I loved dealing with Bob back in the 1990s. Bought a lot of nice stuff from him at fair prices. He was a guy who knew what he was selling, something you don't see as much these days.