t206 prices at Memory Lane--your thoughts

[ullmandds]

My quick impression were the magiewent high! The Cobbs seem priced appropriately. I just quickly scanned the auction and a lot of cards look suspect in grading to me.

[RedsFan1941]

Very bullish market for T206s, especially nice one. Buy and hold rating.

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

My quick impression were the magiewent high! The Cobbs seem priced appropriately. I just quickly scanned the auction and a lot of cards look suspect in grading to me.

Pete, I didn't think the price on the Magie was out of line. There are 129 Magie's in the PSA and SGC pop reports (although I'm sure there are several crossovers and re-subs) with
only four 5's and three higher (one each at 6,7 and 8). The last 5 on VCP that sold was an SGC three years ago for $31,460 and the ML (On the left) is a much stronger 5 in my opinion.
Magie SGC 60 ML.jpg

[rats60]

Originally Posted by Pat R

Pete, I didn't think the price on the Magie was out of line. There are 129 Magie's in the PSA and SGC pop reports (although I'm sure there are several crossovers and re-subs) with
only four 5's and three higher (one each at 6,7 and 8). The last 5 on VCP that sold was an SGC three years ago for $31,460 and the ML (On the left) is a much stronger 5 in my opinion.
Attachment 272354

Neither looks like a 5, what does a PSA 4 sell for?

[GregMitch34]

Bill, wonder what card you thought was doctored....

[Billy5858]

Originally Posted by GregMitch34

Bill, wonder what card you thought was doctored....

My bad. The PSA 5 Howard just had a really bad corner. It went for cheap. I forgot which card I was looking at. But almost looked like there white out on two of the corners. Could have been a bad photo. Didn't mean to accuse PSA

[T206Collector]

Found myself bidding uncontrollably on this one. Now I have to purge 20% of my unsigned collection to pay for it!

[CW]

^^ cool card!

Maybe I underestimated the power of Brown Hindu, but I thought the WaJo PSA 2 portrait had a strong showing at just over $6K. Card was nice for the grade, though, and was downgraded due to back stain.

http://memorylaneinc.com/site/bids/b...e?itemid=43085

[iowadoc77]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

Found myself bidding uncontrollably on this one. Now I have to purge 20% of my unsigned collection to pay for it!

Awesome card! I thought seriously about bidding but knew where it was going so backed off. Will look good in your collection. Congrats!