SOLD: N172 Old Judge Harry Wright HOF Manager Red Stockings

[teza11]

Hi. This has been an interesting process to say the least. I thought I'd share what has happened since my posting to see if other "listers" have experienced similar results (or the lack thereof) on this site.

Within days of my listing I received somewhere between 5-10 offers on the card. They ranged from $200 on the low end to close to $900 on the high end. After a couple days I sent notice to the high bidder accepting his offer and asking how he intended to complete payment. His response was something to the effect of “My offer has expired”. I told him that I wasn’t aware that he had given me an expiration date. He came back to say that "he did not want me to use his offer against him”. I’m not sure how that would work since I never asked him to raise or change his original offer. Unfortunately I turned down a couple other solid offers based on this guy’s offer.

So I circle back to the next remaining best offer. Guy 2 goes through the motions of what are my payment options (even though I clearly stated that in my listing), asks for new conditions i.e. “Will you give my money back if it does not grade at least Auth?”…I agreed, and then even more “I’m busy with work” delays in sending payment. The next pm I get says, “I’m still deciding if I want to buy the card”. Shouldn’t that decision have be made before making me an offer? Maybe it’s just me.

Anyway, it’s been interesting and has left me wondering how many flaky buyers are lurking on this site. Have you experienced something similar?

As for the card, I’ve decided to move it over to eBay.

Jeff

[Leon]

You took your time answering and I don't blame the first guy.
I would probably do the same thing. As for the second guy, if he backed out you should PM me his user id and he might get an infraction or at minimum some questioning as to what his issues are....There shouldn't be too much flakiness in the BST area....LL

Originally Posted by teza11

Hi. This has been an interesting process to say the least. I thought I'd share what has happened since my posting to see if other "listers" have experienced similar results (or the lack thereof) on this site.

Within days of my listing I received somewhere between 5-10 offers on the card. They ranged from $200 on the low end to close to $900 on the high end. After a couple days I sent notice to the high bidder accepting his offer and asking how he intended to complete payment. His response was something to the effect of “My offer has expired”. I told him that I wasn’t aware that he had given me an expiration date. He came back to say that "he did not want me to use his offer against him”. I’m not sure how that would work since I never asked him to raise or change his original offer. Unfortunately I turned down a couple other solid offers based on this guy’s offer.

So I circle back to the next remaining best offer. Guy 2 goes through the motions of what are my payment options (even though I clearly stated that in my listing), asks for new conditions i.e. “Will you give my money back if it does not grade at least Auth?”…I agreed, and then even more “I’m busy with work” delays in sending payment. The next pm I get says, “I’m still deciding if I want to buy the card”. Shouldn’t that decision have be made before making me an offer? Maybe it’s just me.

Anyway, it’s been interesting and has left me wondering how many flaky buyers are lurking on this site. Have you experienced something similar?

As for the card, I’ve decided to move it over to eBay.

Jeff

[bigfish]

I was the flaky buyer who made an offer of 875.00 on this card. I thought my offer was really strong consider it's ghost image. I assumed my offer would be accepted right away or atleast the same day. A few days pass and the seller contacts me saying it's yours. I did say my offered had expired and it did. I generally don't do this but you missed the boat on value of this card. I am sorry for any angst I have created for you. I do wish the best with this card.

Edit: I was the first buyer...