PWCC's 1936 Goudey World Wide Gum DiMaggio PSA 7

[Whodunit]

Evan, could it be that you and "tonya" are still mad that yall didnt get the 51 mays and mantle PSA 8s or the 68 ryan 9 bc yall were too busy trying to beat down prices while Pulice was writing checks?

[BeanTown]

I do not have a pony in the race here. Question for Cortney.... When you submitted the card to Goldin, did you know the card was worked on and put in a New PSA holder as a 7 from an SGC 4 holder?

I think it's obvious that the Goldin winner (John) had no idea it was worked on and regraded. As he must have learned about it only after it was listed with PWCC on Ebay.

Did Goldin know about the card's history when they auctioned it off? What's even more amazing is why didn't someone catch it in the Goldin auction????? It took an Ebay auction to figure it out. Don't people use the VCP to look at high end cards and the POP before making an investment

[Whodunit]

No, I found out that it was doctored 3 days into Brents auction (1yr+ after I bought it and 3 months afyer I sold it). I took my losses when I auctioned it and moved on....never mentioned my loss to anyone. Then I was alerted to this new revelation. I was alerted to this thread by a mutual hobby enthusiast. At that point, Id obviously already sold it but was considering buying it back bc it was 30k under what Id initially paid. If you look at when i quit bidding on Brents auction (i revealed my ebay id letters earlier), and when this thread started, i quit bidding on it as soon as i found out that the card brent sold me was in fact the same card that he bought in REA.

Goldin didnt know anything about the history just like I didnt. The only one involved in this who onew the true story was Brent.....and he's now sold it 2x under false pretenses.