1889 Buck Ewing N29 for sale

[ronniehatesjazz]

I'm always amazed at how hard PSA/SGC grade cards from this era. Should be way higher than a 2 IMO. Lovely card!

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by ronniehatesjazz

I'm always amazed at how hard PSA/SGC grade cards from this era. Should be way higher than a 2 IMO. Lovely card!

I firmly believe it depends on "who" sends it in for grading.....

[thenavarro]

Now that I see the scan on my 32 inch monitor here at work instead of my 4 inch phone display, I think I can see why it graded a 2 initially. Looks like paper loss on the upper right of the back where the S should be in Champions and perhaps along that border. Wish I could have seen that BEFORE I cracked it out of the 2 holder as it would never gotten above a 2 if that's the case, and I wouldn't have cracked and resubmitted.

The joys of being mid forties and having declining vision LOL

Still a beautiful card eye appeal wise and should be a 2 IMHO and not an AUTH.

Mike

[lug-nut]

maybe a dumb question but couldnt you send it back with the original scans and cert # and ask they put the 2 back?

[thenavarro]

Originally Posted by lug-nut

maybe a dumb question but couldnt you send it back with the original scans and cert # and ask they put the 2 back?

No idea, but if it doesn't sell, I might shoot their customer service the scans and see what they say. I hate having to sink more money in it, but that's a great suggestion if they'll do it

M

[thenavarro]

SOLD



Mike