PSA/DNA HOFer Auto Rejections

[prewarsports]

I am sure the Rixey is good.

Cuyler would not surprise me either way, his autograph was all over the place depending on the era he signed it and possibly is one of the most inconsistent of all the HOF players from his era.

Mack is clearly secretarial.

[w7imel]

Originally Posted by prewarsports

I am sure the Rixey is good.

Cuyler would not surprise me either way, his autograph was all over the place depending on the era he signed it and possibly is one of the most inconsistent of all the HOF players from his era.

Mack is clearly secretarial.

How are we determining the Mack as "secretarial"? I've always read Mack rarely if ever used a "ghost" signer. I can accept it being forged but unsure how you come up with secretarial. Mack signatures are everywhere from what I see. Just a question...I just wast further knowledge for myself for the future.

[Exhibitman]

These GDMF auction LOAs are a fraud! I will not bid on an auction with one unless I consider myself sufficiently versed on the signer to have my own view.

As for JSA, I will never, ever use them again for precisely the same reason T26 Collector stated: I had a very expensive signature rejected by JSA over their own auction LOA, and it came from a single-item lot, so there was no 'missing' it.

[RichardSimon]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

These GDMF auction LOAs are a fraud! I will not bid on an auction with one unless I consider myself sufficiently versed on the signer to have my own view.

As for JSA, I will never, ever use them again for precisely the same reason T26 Collector stated: I had a very expensive signature rejected by JSA over their own auction LOA, and it came from a single-item lot, so there was no 'missing' it.

Auction houses are a different breed of client for the TPA's.