T206 Who should be a HOFer that isn't ???

[Topps206]

Originally Posted by Joshchisox08

Some others not mentioned that I completley forgot about:

Cy Seymour ??? .303 average, over 1,700 hits, and 61-56 pitching recrod
Ginger Beaumont ??? .311 average, over 1,700 hits, led the league in 1902 with .357 average
Jesse Tannehill ??? 197-111
Fred Tenney ??? 2231 hits, .294 lifetime average.

Seymour was a better version of Schulte.

Beaumont had a good career, but unlike Cravath, not enough for a short one.

Tannehill is lower on the pole for pitchers.

Tenney is someone I'm surprised Frankie Frisch didn't pick.

[CMIZ5290]

We can beat this thread in the dirt (And I think we have). How about a poll with everyone getting only one player to vote on? I'll start the ball rolling with Ed Reulbach....

[Joshchisox08]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

We can beat this thread in the dirt (And I think we have). How about a poll with everyone getting only one player to vote on? I'll start the ball rolling with Ed Reulbach....

I've been thinking about a poll and was going to bring up the idea earlier but you beat me to it!

I'll edit post #1 and start the list. Right now I'm undecided if we're going to vote just 1 player in.

Anyone think we would get at least 2 votes ??