T206 Tinker To Evers To Chance Grade Opinon

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Psal3891

iPhone. They look great on my phone. I'll go ahead an upload them to my computer then post them up again see if that helps.

Take the pictures closer to the card and straight on instead of at an angle. You can crop them to get rid of everything that is not the card also.

[scooter729]

Good thing the old Adrian 15 post per day rule isn't in effect here.

#2

[Psal3891]

Alright I hope this does the job

[Psal3891]

Back

[Psal3891]

The marking along his face is on the case and the corner everyone keeps calling a diamond cut is not cut its just a nicer corner then the others. No one truly thinks that it cant be a 4.5-5? I cant believe it.

[GasHouseGang]

Originally Posted by Psal3891

The marking along his face is on the case and the corner everyone keeps calling a diamond cut is not cut its just a nicer corner then the others. No one truly thinks that it cant be a 4.5-5? I cant believe it.

Sure, it could be. Submit it and prove them all wrong. Our opinions don't really matter, only the grader you get the day you submit.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Psal3891

The marking along his face is on the case and the corner everyone keeps calling a diamond cut is not cut its just a nicer corner then the others. No one truly thinks that it cant be a 4.5-5? I cant believe it.

do u understand what a diamond cut is?

[T206Collector]

Definitely a diamond cut, but looks like a really great card. I'd say PSA will judge you based on the corners and keep you under a 5; but that SGC would reward you with an SGC 60.

[Psal3891]

Now I do, bnorth just explained to me what it is but it's not trimmed as much as you all wish it was, it's not.

[Psal3891]

Well I've got everything from 2.5-4.5. I still think its def 4-5 so im where I started lol. Correct me if i'm wrong but it seems they grade Carporals less strict then they do Piedmont. Being it's less common? I'm assuming from what I see on ebay but its quite distiguished what they accept for Carporal vs Piedmont. Some Piedmont look like a whole grade higher with the same grade in my opinion.

[T206Collector]

I still think diamond cut on the Evers - looks to me like the 1975 Topps examples in the shared thread.

I now think the Tinker is trimmed at the top. Hard to tell from scans of the face, but I don't like that cut.

Good luck and keep us posted!