Heritage

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

Yeah, it would seem to make sense that Gehrig's rookie would follow in the heels of the M101-5/4 Ruth. They are probably comparable in rarity, in fact the Gehig might actually be a bit scarcer.

I owned a raw NM-MT Gehrig, which turned out to be an SGC 6, bought from Mastro Auctions while on vacation in Mexico some 16 yrs ago. My guess is the Gehrig is somewhere closer to 10x-20x more rare than the Ruth. That's based on what I have seen, is only a guess, and your mileage may vary .

[BeanTown]

Leon, I remember that card and it was awesome!! Didn't an autograph version of his rookie card go for like 30k not too long ago? I completely agree with Kevin and others that the 1925 Exhibit of Gehrig is way under valued. Here is the scan of the Heritage Gehrig.

[bcbgcbrcb]

Here was my Gehrig Exhibit RC sold in Goodwin Auction - July, 2014. Admittedly not as nice as the Heritage example but $2,400 compared to whatever this one goes for....

Unbelievable! Boy, do I know how to pick which cards to sell and which cards to hold on to.........

[itjclarke]

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb

Here was my Gehrig Exhibit RC sold in Goodwin Auction - July, 2014. Admittedly not as nice as the Heritage example but $2,400 compared to whatever this one goes for....

Unbelievable! Boy, do I know how to pick which cards to sell and which cards to hold on to.........

I was underbidder on a 2, sold at about $2400 right around that same time, also on Goodwin. Kicking myself hard for passing on that one. Glad to have since picked up a like pose '27 Exhibit though.

[glchen]

One word of caution about the 1925 Exhibits Gehrig is that it is often mislabeled by the TPG's with the 1926 version which looks exactly the same, but has a bluish tint. For example, here is one that sold on ebay Link, that looks like it is a mislabeled 1926 version due to the bluish tint. Of course, the 1926 Exhibits is actually rarer than the 1925 one.

[bcbgcbrcb]

WOW, Gary, even if it is a '25 as labeled, a $10K sale for a card with multiple heavy creases across the entire width of the card seems crazy when mine being much nicer sold for $2,400....Geez......

[glchen]

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb

WOW, Gary, even if it is a '25 as labeled, a $10K sale for a card with multiple heavy creases across the entire width of the card seems crazy when mine being much nicer sold for $2,400....Geez......

Hi Phil, actually according to watchcount, this card was sold via Best Offer for "only" $5500.

[Vintageclout]

Originally Posted by Leon

I owned a raw NM-MT Gehrig, which turned out to be an SGC 6, bought from Mastro Auctions while on vacation in Mexico some 16 yrs ago. My guess is the Gehrig is somewhere closer to 10x-20x more rare than the Ruth. That's based on what I have seen, is only a guess, and your mileage may vary .

Leon - on a sheer "pop" basis (PSA & SGC), Gehrig rookie approx. 2.5X scarcer. If you take into account raw copies, I would guess 3-4X would be the number.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Vintageclout

Leon - on a sheer "pop" basis (PSA & SGC), Gehrig rookie approx. 2.5X scarcer. If you take into account raw copies, I would guess 3-4X would be the number.

It seems like I see a lot more Ruth rookies than Gehrigs. But if the pop report says it ain't so, who am I to argue?

[Bigb13]

Catalogs should be here today. They said they were going out on Monday.

[rats60]

Originally Posted by Bigb13

Catalogs should be here today. They said they were going out on Monday.

I got mine today.