1951 Bowman RC Willie Mays PSA 6 and PSA 4 -Sold

[Leon]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Fair enough, $2k for the PSA 6, thanks...

ok, the offer is $8600 now, your turn.

[pokerplyr80]

Tough crowd. Those seem like reasonable prices for an iconic and hot card. Good luck with your sale.

He is right when a price is listed it should be up to the potential buyer to make an offer if he wants a discount. For those sellers who refuse to list prices asking for one is reasonable.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

Tough crowd. Those seem like reasonable prices for an iconic and hot card. Good luck with your sale.

He is right when a price is listed it should be up to the potential buyer to make an offer if he wants a discount. For those sellers who refuse to list prices asking for one is reasonable.

Really Jesse? SMR price for a PSA 6 is $5200, he wants $8500 for an off centered card. Also, the hot run of top rookies has mainly been very high graded cards (8's and higher)

[gnaz01]

VCP shows this last one sold most recently for $15K a few weeks ago, albeit a better centered example:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1951-Bowman-...p2047675.l2557

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by gnaz01

VCP shows this last one sold most recently for $15K a few weeks ago, albeit a better centered example:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1951-Bowman-...p2047675.l2557

Baffling Greg, but I saw the card. Perfectly centered, but bad wax stains on the back. SMR price for a 7 is $11,500, this card in a 6 sells for $15K, and PSA adjusts these SMR prices on a regular basis. Does not make any sense at all...

[1952boyntoncollector]

Cards sold...amazingly for a lot more than SMR...hard to believe...took what 4 or so days and no 'price reductions'

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

Cards sold...amazingly for a lot more than SMR...hard to believe...took what 4 or so days and no 'price reductions'

Congrats Jake! It just goes to show that even a blind squirrel can find an acorn.....Who was the lucky buyer by the way??

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Really Jesse? SMR price for a PSA 6 is $5200, he wants $8500 for an off centered card. Also, the hot run of top rookies has mainly been very high graded cards (8's and higher)

Agreed that most of the run on the rookies has been higher grade, but the Mantle and Mays have always held value well at the lower grades. And SMR? Who looks at SMR for high end cards? It's rarely accurate. A centered 6 just went for 15k. A 7 is sitting at over 19k with a couple of hours left. Not centered. 8k for a 6 will look like a bargain soon.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

Agreed that most of the run on the rookies has been higher grade, but the Mantle and Mays have always held value well at the lower grades. And SMR? Who looks at SMR for high end cards? It's rarely accurate. A centered 6 just went for 15k. A 7 is sitting at over 19k with a couple of hours left. Not centered. 8k for a 6 will look like a bargain soon.

Fair enough. I'll make this simple mathematics. A PSA 6 Mays (supposedly) sold for $15K. Mantle is worth considerably more than double the SMR price of Mays ($11,500 vs. $5200). I have a PSA 6 Mantle that I would be more than happy to sell for $30K. Please email me for PPal info...

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Fair enough. I'll make this simple mathematics wise. A PSA 6 Mays (supposedly) sold for $15K. Mantle is more than double the SMR price of Mays. I have a PSA 6 Mantle that I would be more than happy to sell for $30K. Please email me for PPal info...

Why not list your Mantle and we can discuss the aspects of a price you ask for (if you even put a price)...thats the future of b/s/t on net54?

Also if you going to quote SMR for key cards its a bit silly especially when you cant point to any listings that are selling a similar card for that ...

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Fair enough. I'll make this simple mathematics. A PSA 6 Mays (supposedly) sold for $15K. Mantle is worth considerably more than double the SMR price of Mays ($11,500 vs. $5200). I have a PSA 6 Mantle that I would be more than happy to sell for $30K. Please email me for PPal info...

Since you seem to think SMR is so accurate I will offer you SMR + 25% for your 51 Mantle. Sight unseen. I will, of course, want to verify scans before transferring funds, but I can send tonight if you can ship tomorrow.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

Since you seem to think SMR is so accurate I will offer you SMR + 25% for your 51 Mantle. Sight unseen. I will, of course, want to verify scans before transferring funds, but I can send tonight if you can ship tomorrow.

please see post# 12....

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by Leon

ok, the offer is $8600 now, your turn.

Come on Leon, what exactly are you getting at?? This guy has been a parasite on numerous threads I have made along with a ton of other N54 members. I did what you asked, I made him an offer, of which he has yet to decline....

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Come on Leon, what exactly are you getting at?? This guy has been a parasite on numerous threads I have made along with a ton of other N54 members. I did what you asked, I made him an offer, of which he has yet to decline....

CMIZE- Seriously? its a b/s/t thread...i dont think its appropriate to comment negatively on b/s/t in most situations...i dont think i said anything in this thread for you to act like juvenile here and talking down a card price, all i did was put an asking price and list a card and you are acting inappropriately here and i think everyone woudl agree

i would think if someone is selling a cards in the 10k range, it would be polite to keep the schoolboy antics in another thread, unless you are schoolboy rowe...

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

CMIZE- Seriously? its a b/s/t thread...i dont think its appropriate to comment negatively on b/s/t in most situations...i dont think i said anything in this thread for you to act like juvenile here and talking down a card price, all i did was put an asking price and list a card and you are acting inappropriately here and i think everyone woudl agree

i would think if someone is selling a cards in the 10k range, it would be polite to keep the schoolboy antics in another thread, unless you are schoolboy rowe...

Schoolboy Rowe? Fantastic pitcher for the Tigers, nice compliment...

[1952boyntoncollector]

CMIZE is at it again.


Here we go again...everyone was quoting SMR on those green cobbs, and the 1952 Mays, and the 1952 PSA 7.5 banks...people ask why i bring those up..because history continues to repeat itself..i have another wiseguy bring up SMR , which shouldnt even be discussed on b/s/t by the way..

I guess Leon cant ask for more than SMR on this cards either...SMR is the only thing that matters apparently..

[CMIZ5290]

You are right about the SMR price comments, I do apologize for that....