Anyone ever have PSA damage a card on review?

[Griffins]

I had a '15 CJ Hofer with a case that was cracked. Sent it in for reholdering and in doing so they bent it. It was downgraded to a 3 from a 5, and they said since it was in a cracked holder it wasn't their fault.

[Kingcobb]

I had a card damaged by PSA during grading, lucky for me it was a T206 common Knight portrait they contacted me and gave me the value that was listed in their price guide for a PSA 4 which I thought was fair also returned the card which had a corner bent over that was not there when submitted. I believe that was back in 2013.

[ls7plus]

Had a '70 Topps Reggie Jackson in NrMt-Mt graded a "5" because of a ding in a corner that it did not have when submitted. I just chalked it up to experience, and basically ceased submitting raw cards, choosing instead to buy the cards I wanted already graded.

Interesting post,

Larry

[Republicaninmass]

This got me thinking, recently I sent in one of those low pop cards, thinking it had a shot at a 5, came back a three! Look at the lower left!

Is the juice worth the squeeze?



Before



After

[Bliggity]

I had PSA damage a corner also...the same lower-left corner, actually. Sent it in raw, hoping for a 5.

[Republicaninmass]

same sub, lower left again! I thought this card was a 6!





[IMG][/IMG]

[Bliggity]

Maybe that's why they put the raised "PSA" logo right over the bottom corners on the front and back - so it obscures the damage!