Heritage vs Robert Edward to consign

[airhed4]

I got a few pre WW II PSA 8 and aboves. Looking for best auction site to sell on. Thoughts? I believe I have narrowed it down to these two based on what I see the cards selling for on their website but concerned about payment and timing. Am I going to wait months with one of them or will I settle quick and not worry? I have never let an auction house sell a card of mine. Thanks

[4815162342]

The PMs and emails are gonna start flyin'!

[spacktrack]

I'm happy to discuss specifics about consigning if you'd like to give me a call, but I can say that we pay all consignors within approximately 30 days of the end of the auction (the last few auctions have been closer to three weeks). For millions and millions of dollars worth of items sold to hundreds of different buyers around the world, we think this is an exceptional turnaround time. I think many here can attest to the quick settlement of auction proceeds when consigning to us. We also allow netting out invoices if you decide to win something in the auction, so that can put items/money in your pocket even quicker. We can also offer cash advances upfront. Lots of options, but all are geared towards you getting your money as quickly as possible.

Brian Dwyer
Robert Edward Auctions
908-226-9900

[sbfinley]

You probably can't go wrong with either, although I occasional miss a Heritage auction thinking it's just another monthly. REA, however, is an event that is akin to Christmas morning for some of us.

[Bicem]

[GregMitch34]

Brian's a great guy, if that matters. I had some strangeness with Heritage on none-sports auctions.

[joeadcock]

..

[Shoeless Moe]

I think its a toss up in terms of results, but he ain't lying about the payout, weeks compared to months (and I've consigned with both).

[iwantitiwinit]

Rea

[Bobsbats]

While I am a smaller collector in terms of this forum, I do wait for my REA catalog like a little kid....as opposed to Heritages monthly
auctions...just my .02

[gnaz01]

Payments are lightning quick and both Rob and Brian (hey guys) are awesome and very intelligent within the hobby.

[Bicem]

I'd go REA over Heritage, both get results but REA customer service is top notch.

[frankbmd]

"Auction ends Sunday morning.

Consignment check in hand Wednesday."

BST

Brian and REA also very timely.

[ullmandds]

rea cust service is as good as it gets.

[kmac32]

Have dealt with both and no issues with either. REA was a little more personable in my oinion.

[ValKehl]

A poll would be most interesting!

FWIIW, I would choose REA over Heritage in a heartbeat. Although relatively new, LOTG would be another good choice, IMHO.
Val

[Bpm0014]

I like REA. Heritage website for auctions is most annoying and confusing. I have an account with Heritage but don't even bid anymore because their auction website is so confusing

[iowadoc77]

Probably good either way but that REA catalog. Little bit like Christmas when that comes. Poor mailman. That thing is heavy.

[BeanTown]

Website
1 Heritage
2 REA

Getting advances
Tie

Paid after conclusion of auction
1 REA
2 Heritage

Catalog pictures and descriptions
Tie

Mailing List and overall eyes that view lots
1 Heritage (many cross over customers from their other auctions)
2. REA

[Stampsfan]

I consigned a couple of items that garnered 4 figure bids, for the first time with Heritage in their November 2015 major auction. A couple of comments...
1. The communication beforehand was, to say the least, mediocre. I had to track them down a few times before we settled everything. I'm guessing my $1,500-$5,000 items were not too important, when compared to half a million dollar '52 Topps Mantle cards.
2. It took until Christmas before the mailed out the cheques; I got the cheque between Christmas and New Years. So 7-8 weeks later approximately.
3. They charged me a few hundred dollars for "authentication fees". None of this was ever discussed beforehand, and I only found out about these additional fees (not included in the 15% consignment fees) when the cheque arrived and it was documented. Frustrating, because one of the LOA's I had was directly from the 49ers; there was no need for an additional Heritage LOA that they charged me for.

Full disclosure... I have zero consignment experience with REA.

[MGHPro]

I've consigned with rea several times and never with heritage . Rea paid quickly and have very good communication ... Also no hidden fees .
Matt

[Shoeless Moe]

ah yes forgot about Heritage's hidden fees for the consignor. I consigned an item that came with a MEARS LOA and then they add a PSA and charge me for that, which I'm sure because of the volume they do they pay very little while making yet another profit on me the consignor.

And yes their Customer Service used to be good, but the past year or 2 is weak at best.


In addition to REA I also like SCP & Goldin. Consigned to all 3, no issues.

[Gradedcardman]

I decided on REA for a couple of reasons. Mainly that their auctions are what a lot of collectors seem to anticipate during the year. On top of that, all of my dealings with REA, whether consigner or buyer have been very positive.