Thoughts on 1953 Mantle Topps card

[CW]

Originally Posted by irv

Surprised at the grade on this one, considering the left border.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1953-TOPPS-8...gAAOSwnipWbFKQ

I can see how that might look bad, but it's actually just a factory "rough cut". It wouldn't be considered damage. If it's common for a set then the grader will not downgrade a card for a factory rough cut. Some collectors steer clear of rough cuts, while others like the look of them. You will at least know that edge hasn't been trimmed.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

Irv, 19 watching just means that 19 people are following the auction. People can choose to watch auctions by hitting a button on the auction listing. People watch for a variety of reasons. I have watched auctions to: a) return and bid after I do some research; b) see what a card ultimately sells for; or c) track whether someone lowers the starting bid on something after it doesn't sell. It's an indication a card is interesting to some people but not an indication that a card will ultimately sell.

Thanks for the explanation.

Originally Posted by CW

I can see how that might look bad, but it's actually just a factory "rough cut". It wouldn't be considered damage. If it's common for a set then the grader will not downgrade a card for a factory rough cut. Some collectors steer clear of rough cuts, while others like the look of them. You will at least know that edge hasn't been trimmed.

Understood, but it does make me question why factory cut, off centre cards are graded for much less, as they are also factory cut, but I assume they those are more common than a rough edge/border?

Appreciate the info.

[jmb]

Beautiful 53 and 57 Jeff.