$400+ for 1952T Mantle....

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

I wouldn't buy that card to keep, only to flip. In an authentic holder I would take a shot around 2k. I would be confident I could sell it for at least 3k.

I'm not saying I love the card at 3k just that I think someone else would.

right so you don't even know if you buy it for 2k but you think it would go for 3k-3500..thats the first sign that your valuation is too high, which I think you were already beginning to admit..

[Bestdj777]

I think the valuation is spot on. I remember shopping before this recent spike and some really nasty cards were bringing 2k plus then. Given the difficulty of getting a low grade example at any reasonable price now I'd imagine you could find a buyer at 3k if you didn't mind holding it a couple months.

[begsu1013]

depending on the day and the mood, i'd throw $3k at it if it were in a sgc/psa holder but doubt i would win it...

it's got 2 things going for it:

it's a legit 52 mantle.
and it's a very unique and laughable 52 mantle.

it'd make me smile!

hell, i'd even prop it up on the desk at work just for the facial reactions...

(again, if it were legit)

[begsu1013]

and yes, I have a couple of bags...

a serious one.
a sunday one.
and one that is more nuttier than a squirrel turd.