New game-used cards

[Tradegeek]

It is disgusting IMHO. Game used Derek Jeter, fine. I'm sure every piece of equipment that touched his body in a game since 1993 has been saved. But Cobb? Honus Wagner? Not only can a slice of bat have no provenance (an actual intact bat can be researched) why is it acceptable to destroy something so rare?

I'm just waiting for Topps to purchase a copy of the Declaration of Independence. John Handcock cut signature superfractor anyone?

[JTysver]

I agree. The object should be to preserve the history, not destroy it.
Think of it like this. In the sports world a Babe Ruth Game used bat or game used Uniform is the Mona Lisa of Sports Memorabilia. If there are 5-10 Ruth Bats in the world, that is like 5-10 Rembrandts. I wouldn't cut them up.

Would anyone want the Mona Lisa (Da Vinci) being cut up and placed in packs to be parceled out?

[packs]

Not accusing any companies of anything but I find it really hard to believe that any of the cards made are what they're advertised as. Why would you cut up an authentic bat when you can just sell a cheap one in its place? And how would anyone know?

None of the companies have ever been compelled to show receipts for the items they've supposedly packaged into their products and if you ask them for proof of purchase I highly doubt you'll receive anything.

[swarmee]

http://www.blowoutcards.com/forums/b...bat-1-1-a.html

As I have said, the companies are putting real bats and jerseys (or pants) into cards. They help sell their products, and give 1000 people a chance to have a personal holy grail card. I am not for it, but I certainly understand it.

[JustinD]

There are cases of Ruth and other cut autos being proved fake and the company taking them back and replacing it. If the game used item can be proven fake the company not only risks their reputation, they are obligated to replace the item with a real one.

These are real items and the card companies were in the past years some of the largest buyers of these items. Game used are somewhat in the same realm as butterfly collars right now as something that has passed its prime due to flooding the market. But, these are real items.

Think how many chase cards you can create from one bat? One bat can create ruth or cobb cards for several years. You can likely get well over a 1000 cards with the thin silvers they put in. The companies more than get their money back.

I don't like it, but as they are huge buyers it helped the memorabilia market values.

[Rich Klein]

And in one "humorous" case -- the card company put an autograph of Eddie Plank as a rare cut into I think it was SP Legendary Cuts BUT the autographs was Eddie Plank -- however it was the Ed Plank who pitched for the Giants briefly in the 1970's.

Look mistakes occur but that one was a doozy.

Rich

[Rookiemonster]

Didn't upperdeck get caught buying and using fake jerseys ? It could have been a different company but I think it was upperdeck .

I'll one step further . Do you believe that packs are randomly inserted ? Or do you think if a card is number to 50 that there are 50 of them out there .

I would love to see a pull registry formed . When you buy some product you can log on and enter what you pulled . I think that would be fun and inlighting .