8K for an altered 51B Mantle?

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

Is it definitely the same card, crossed over (perhaps to hide its origins)?

Looking at the Goodwin scans I assumed it was probably trimmed to center it or perhaps had a touch up. Would it sell for as much if there was a full description of the alterations as appeared in Heritage?

Authentic cards are a whole different animal than PSA 1s.......the eye appeal is paid for on a much greater scale then PSA 1s..and I not surprised to see authentics go up to psa 3-4 range in terms of market value ...

basically on psa 1s you focus on what is good on the card...on authentics a lot of times they point out to what is bad on the card because a lot of times everything looks really good otherwise