Charles Comiskey Cut Auto 1/1 BGS 9.5

[Buckswin07]

Actually, it does. The Y finishes the same way. So your saying the cards depiction on whose signature is on the front is incorrect?

[Buckswin07]

The card also says he's a HOF baseball player and helped form the American Leauge. His son did none of that, no? And the Picture on the front...who is that?

[CMIZ5290]

This is not the autograph of the original Charles Comiskey, it's not even close....

[Buckswin07]

After further research, it does indeed appear to not be that of Comiskey. I'm looking into Sportkings on the matter. Thanks for everyone's input!

[tazdmb]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

After further research, it does indeed appear to not be that of Comiskey. I'm looking into Sportkings on the matter. Thanks for everyone's input!

Good luck, the picture in front is indeed that of the HOFer Comiskey.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by tazdmb

Good luck, the picture in front is indeed that of the HOFer Comiskey.

Yes it is, it appears the representation from Beckett was a tad dicey at best....

[Buckswin07]

Thank you. Already looks to be made right!

http://www.blowoutcards.com/forums/v...skey-auto.html

[theshleps]

Just look at any of the HOF Comiskey autographs or look in Ron's book. It is the grandson 100%

[Danny Smith]

Big miss by Beckett but glad it's gonna get fixed.

[chaddurbin]

blind leading the blind. glad OP finally relented so you guys can help him get an actual authentic sig of the more famous comiskey....ridiculous.

[Buckswin07]

Originally Posted by chaddurbin

blind leading the blind. glad OP finally relented so you guys can help him get an actual authentic sig of the more famous comiskey....ridiculous.

Besides your attitude in the above post, what's ridiculous about people pointing out that signature is not THE Charles Comiskeys? Obviously, at first I would be skeptical on other people's opinions. The reason is simply because the card I was holding stated otherwise.

[Bpm0014]

I think what he's saying is that you need to do your due diligence and know the difference between the two before you just purchase something blindly and then later post it for sale for $2000+. The above looks NOTHING like "the real Comiskey's" autograph. Not even close. I don't think he was being rude...

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

Besides your attitude in the above post, what's ridiculous about people pointing out that signature is not THE Charles Comiskeys? Obviously, at first I would be skeptical on other people's opinions. The reason is simply because the card I was holding stated otherwise.

What is ridiculous is Sport Kings with their "authentic" autographs and your willingness to accept these as authentic without doing the due diligence and listening to the knowledgeable folks on this board (i.e. your argumentative diatribe AFTER you were told this card is Commy's son)

[scmavl]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

Besides your attitude in the above post, what's ridiculous about people pointing out that signature is not THE Charles Comiskeys? Obviously, at first I would be skeptical on other people's opinions. The reason is simply because the card I was holding stated otherwise.

I think the reason he used that tone is because you joined this forum two months ago where many members have DECADES of autograph expertise and immediately argued when they told you what was blatantly obvious, even to someone as green as me. I saw it and immediately thought "Doesn't Comiskey usually sign with very curly C's and in fountain pen? Weird..."

If you want to get the most out of this forum, sit back, read, and learn. There is a wealth of knowledge here that these guys freely share. It's worth your time.

Good luck and glad the company is making it right with you.