Timeline of Demmitt & O'Hara (St Louis cards). Show us your Demmitt & O'Hara cards

[sreader3]

As a final note of support for the "Midwestern bias" theory for Polar Bear, I would note that Factory 6 was in Middleton, Ohio (Luhrman & Wilburn Tobacco Company) -- about halfway between St. Louis and Cleveland.

[tedzan]

Hi Scot

Listed here are the current POP report (PSA + SGC) numbers of the following cards of Nicholls (batting)......

AB 350 ........... 10
DRUM ............... 2
EPDG .............. 14
OLD MILL .......... 8
POLAR BEAR .... 13
SOVEREIGN ..... 12
TOLSTOI ......... 12


I'm curious as to how these numbers compare with your survey ?









TED Z
.

[Thromdog]

Couple more......
polar.jpg

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by Thromdog

Couple more......
Attachment 215240

Hi Jeff

Thanks for posting your Demmitt and O'Hara cards.

Unless I'm missing something, your Demmitt looks like it deserves better than an SGC 20 grade.


TED Z
.

[Thromdog]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Unless I'm missing something, your Demmitt looks like it deserves better than an SGC 20 grade.


TED Z
.

It's definitely "polar bear" dirty but has a slight loss above his ear. would probably get a 2-2.5 otherwise. My scanner hates graded cards.

I love the card though......

[Jantz]

Ted & Scot

Thank you once again for your willingness to share your knowledge and experience. It is appreciated.

Ted

I should have known that you would have a Nichols (batting) with a PB back. And its a beauty as well!

No O'Hara yet, but here is my Demmitt.

Jantz

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by Jantz

Ted & Scot

Thank you once again for your willingness to share your knowledge and experience. It is appreciated.

Ted

I should have known that you would have a Nichols (batting) with a PB back. And its a beauty as well!

No O'Hara yet, but here is my Demmitt.

Jantz

I always appreciate your kind words, good buddy.


If you are looking for a Nicholls / POLAR BEAR card, I have an extra one somewhere in my T206 archives that I can send you.

Email me your mailing address and I will send it to you.

tedzan11@comcast.net


TED Z
.

[sreader3]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Hi Scot

Listed here are the current POP report (PSA + SGC) numbers of the following cards of Nicholls (batting)......

AB 350 ........... 10
DRUM ............... 2
EPDG .............. 14
OLD MILL .......... 8
POLAR BEAR .... 13
SOVEREIGN ..... 12
TOLSTOI ......... 12


I'm curious as to how these numbers compare with your survey?

TED Z
.

Hi Ted, Have been away from the board for a couple of days. I'll see what I can track down re Nichols pops. Scot

[sreader3]

AB 350 ........... 0
DRUM ............ 0
EPDG ............. 3
OLD MILL ........ 3
POLAR BEAR .... 4
SOVEREIGN ..... 4
TOLSTOI ......... 3

For comparison:

PIEDMONT 350 .... 43
SWEET CAPORAL 350 .... 44

Seems pretty proportionate to your data except I didn't see any AB 350s during 2008 - 2013 time frame.

[tedzan]

Do you really mean........

AB 350......... 7- 3 = 10
Drum......... 0- 2 = 2
EPDG......... 10- 5 = 15
Old Mill......... 5- 4 = 9
Polar Bear......... 4- 9 = 13
Sov 350......... 5- 7- = 12
Tolstoi........ 7- 7 = 14


Then thanks for confirming my numbers. The slight difference on a couple of your #'s vs. my #'s is most likely because your's are more current than mine.



TED Z
.

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by sreader3

AB 350 ........... 0
DRUM ............ 0
EPDG ............. 3
OLD MILL ........ 3
POLAR BEAR .... 4
SOVEREIGN ..... 4
TOLSTOI ......... 3

For comparison:

PIEDMONT 350 .... 43
SWEET CAPORAL 350 .... 44

Seems pretty proportionate to your data except I didn't see any AB 350s during 2008 - 2013 time frame.

Thanks Scot for this data on Nicholls.

If my recollection is accurate, you have one of the nicest Nicholls / AB 350 cards that I have seen. I have been trying to acquire an upgrade on my Nicholls / AB 350 cards for over 9
years and haven't found one yet.

Furthermore, your numbers regarding Nicholls with AB 350 and DRUM backs appear to support my theory that he was removed early in the press runs of those 2 backs and replaced
with Jake Stahl.


TED Z
.

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Do you really mean........

AB 350......... 7- 3 = 10
Drum......... 0- 2 = 2
EPDG......... 10- 5 = 15
Old Mill......... 5- 4 = 9
Polar Bear......... 4- 9 = 13
Sov 350......... 5- 7- = 12
Tolstoi........ 7- 7 = 14


Then thanks for confirming my numbers. The slight difference on a couple of your #'s vs. my #'s is most likely because your's are more current than mine.



TED Z
.

Ted,

Yes, your pop report numbers are correct with the exception of a few SGC
examples that have the Nicholls spelling on the grading label instead of
Nichols which is correct for the batting version.

Here are two Tolstois, one of each spelling.
http://photos.imageevent.com/patrick...%20Tolstoi.png

http://photos.imageevent.com/patrick...%20Tolstoi.png

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Hi Scot

Listed here are the current POP report (PSA + SGC) numbers of the following cards of Nicholls (batting)......

AB 350 ........... 10
DRUM ............... 2
EPDG .............. 14
OLD MILL .......... 8
POLAR BEAR .... 13
SOVEREIGN ..... 12
TOLSTOI ......... 12







TED Z
.

Ted,

SGC has a few Nichols (batting) listed as Nicholls (batting) in their pop reports
namely two Tolstoi's and one each of Old Mill and EPDG.

This is what the current SGC and PSA pop reports show.


PSA SGC Total


AB 350......... 7- 3- 10
Drum......... 0- 2- 2
EPDG......... 10- 5- 15
Old Mill......... 5- 4- 9
Polar Bear......... 4- 9- 13
Sov 350......... 5- 7- 12
Tolstoi........ 7- 7- 14