Random thoughts on 1915 CJS; tough cards, o/c cards, tilt...

[GregMitch34]

Anthony, still wondering those grades were on the cards that crossed successfully to PSA...

[Griffins]

SGC80 to SGC88, crossing mostly straight across PSA 6 to 8.

[terjung]

You mentioned that you think Rickey is the toughest HOFer in the '15 set. In your opinion, how does he rank in terms of overall toughness compared to some of the commons you mentioned?

It seems like there aren't that many cards of Rickey as s player. For a guy that made such an impact on the game later in life, it'd be nice if there were more to choose from.

[rainier2004]

Originally Posted by terjung

You mentioned that you think Rickey is the toughest HOFer in the '15 set. In your opinion, how does he rank in terms of overall toughness compared to some of the commons you mentioned?

It seems like there aren't that many cards of Rickey as s player. For a guy that made such an impact on the game later in life, it'd be nice if there were more to choose from.

There definitely isn't a lot to choose from with Rickey as a player, I believe he only played in 3 seasons with 1914 being his last. Its curious the Cracker Jack even produced a 1914 card for him considering he didn't play in 1913 if my memory is correct.

I think the commons I mentioned would be tougher on my list, I did get the Rickey well before I was near the end, but I was also looking for one for a couple years. The commons just didn't appear for me. Maybe its cycles, maybe fewer mid grades change hands for whatever reason.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by Griffins

SGC80 to SGC88, crossing mostly straight across PSA 6 to 8.

Are you kidding me?? SGC grades have not been close to crossing to the same PSA grades. Maybe you have had a 4 leaf clover in your pocket, but it would be a complete rarity if so, especially with T206s....