Alexander Cartwright Founding Fathers Sportkings 2008 1/1 auto

[Buckswin07]

Originally Posted by tazdmb

Please don't take this the wrong way, but I have a few issues with the card, the biggest being that it looks as though the autograph appears to be from a letter press and not an original signature. You can tell from the cut that this was taken from a letter, as opposed to a bank document-as he signed his common "very truly yours" above based on the dips in the "y" at the top of the cut-and hundreds of these letter press exists. Plus, the way the paper the cut is on is wrinkled, it appears likely that onionskin paper was used. Finally, the ink is bleeding and not "crisp". My guess is that you would have a much better opportunity of getting the price you are looking for is getting a reputable TPA to certify the autograph itself.

Thank you for your comments. A few things. The card was originally graded a BGS 9 with a "7" in the auto. I did not like the way the 7 looked so I decided to have the card reslabbed by Beckett in the present holder. The autograph is authentic. I hear you on your letterpress comment but that cannot be confirmed. Furthermore, the "very truly yours" comment is a bit general because your assuming he signed that just about every time he signed his name and I doubt that. However, if he did, perhaps it IS is just above his signature and not in the autograph window shown above. If you do not belive that the auto is authentic, your questioning Dr. Price at SK and the auto grading staff at Beckett.

[packs]

I think the real question is whether or not this is a letter press signature. A letter press signature is a copy of an actual signature, sort of like an early fax. The signature on this card looks very similar to this letter press signature, right down to the tone of the paper and ink. I think this card contains a copy of a signature and not the original. Have a look:

http://www.sigauctions.com/lot-5971.aspx

[Buckswin07]

Originally Posted by packs

I think the real question is whether or not this is a letter press signature. A letter press signature is a copy of an actual signature, sort of like an early fax. The signature on this card looks very similar to this letter press signature, right down to the tone of the paper and ink. I think this card contains a copy of a signature and not the original. Have a look:

http://www.sigauctions.com/lot-5971.aspx

The paper in your link is clearly different paper than on my card. I'm familier with the letter press copies. I know the authenticity of the card is guaranteed by SK.

[tazdmb]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

If you do not belive that the auto is authentic, your questioning Dr. Price at SK and the auto grading staff at Beckett.

First of all, Beckett does not authenticate autographs-they have JSA do that for them, which I assume they did not do in this case. All beckett did was grade the strength of the signature-but they assumed it was authentic-which goes back to the original issue. If you give me Dr. Price's contact, I would be happy to contact him.

You may want to even list it on ebay, and get a quick opinion. I will even make you a deal-post the quick opinion for us to see I will reimburse you the $10 (assuming it doesn't come back as questionable-because you get a full refund if it does) either way-so you have nothing to lose! Ask people on the board, my word is good and you will get paid.

[tazdmb]

Just saw, this-I think Dr. Price and Beckett must get some things wrong from time-to-time. You really don't think this is real, do you?!

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by tazdmb

Just saw, this-I think Dr. Price and Beckett must get some things wrong from time-to-time. You really don't think this is real, do you?!

Obviously you can't see in your pic, but doing research online, the card does state on the back it is a wife signature.

[Buckswin07]

Originally Posted by tazdmb

Just saw, this-I think Dr. Price and Beckett must get some things wrong from time-to-time. You really don't think this is real, do you?!

Swing and a miss on this theory. Says right on the back who signed it

[Buckswin07]

Your paying my $10 to put it on ebay? I don't understand.

[sbfinley]

My first instinct was that something was off as well, but I don't have it in hand so I won't say anything either way. Yes though, trading card companies make MAJOR mistakes on occasion. Probably the most famous cut card in history (the Topps 27' Yankees booklet, had to have a handful of signatures replaced because they ended up bad.

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

Your paying my $10 to put it on ebay? I don't understand.

I believe what he is trying to say is that PSA/DNA provides a "Quick Opinion" service for eBay auctions (maybe others?). It's around a $10 fee for them to look at the eBay auction (which is why he told you to list it). So, I'm betting that's what he's referring to.

If it's comes back authentic (I'm not familiar with the sig so hence the "if") you would be able to send it in for the full authentication service and they subtract that Quick Opinion fee from the total.

List your item for free as a BIN and go to the PSA/DNA Quick Opinion, submit a request for said opinion, then he would reimburse you the fee.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[tazdmb]

Yes to above , provided you post it and it doesn't come back as unable to determine, as you would be reimbursed your money back regardless.

[Buckswin07]

Is anyone in this thread interested in the card? Or are you simply questioning it? If it's the later, thanks for your thoughts. If there is interest, then I would certainly be willing to send it in to PSA/DNA.

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Originally Posted by Buckswin07

Is anyone in this thread interested in the card? Or are you simply questioning it? If it's the later, thanks for your thoughts. If there is interest, then I would certainly be willing to send it in to PSA/DNA.

Wouldn't you have the slightest concern about the authenticity towards this card? At least 3 people came on here about the question to the authenticity.

If it were me, I would like to get that all squared away if it's authentic before trying to move it. If not, you'll even have a worse mess on your hands. If it isn't, you would get a monstrous replacement in return I would bet.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[doug.goodman]

I see nothing on the Sportkings website that mentions how they backup their "guarantee".

Also, I'm curious why you removed the card from a slab that was "originally graded a BGS 9 with a "7" in the auto" and put it in a slab that doesn't mention any grades at all. Seems like 9 & 7 would be better than nothing & nothing, but I could be wrong.

Maybe you should have had Dmitri Young resubmit it for you, he had a knack for getting 10s.

Doug

[Buckswin07]

Back to the top

[Buckswin07]

Available!

[Buckswin07]

Looking for the next owner.

[Bestdj777]

Good luck with the sale.

[Buckswin07]

Card has SOLD thank you!