T206 Ty Cobb OLD MILL (Green Portrait) 1909-11 White Border [Reverse Auction]

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

+1

can be talking about the card too...

[filmmaker]

11/02/2015 $7,000 usd

I did not go to Hollywood. Thanks for your laugh.
I was in negotiations but the deal fell through.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by filmmaker

11/02/2015 $7,000 usd

I did not go to Hollywood. Thanks for your laugh.
I was in negotiations but the deal fell through.

you just unilaterally emailed me about a price I would pay.....I would like to let the auction run its course....I thought that's why you have it at auction afterall...

deals typically fall through when there is a reverse auction going on...if we knew what price increments you were using that will help....maybe the guy that the deal fell through with will jump back in here when the card goes down closer to the price he wants to pay...maybe you think it will sell for more than he wants and that was why it fell through.....time will tell (if you really are planning to sell it here at auction)

I got a feeling this card will sell before we ever see a 'ill take it' here

[filmmaker]

I didnt ask you what you would pay for it?
I simply asked "what you thought it would sell for"

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by filmmaker

I didnt ask you what you would pay for it?
I simply asked "what you thought it would sell for"

I noticed your comment on the Reverse Auction Forum. Please let me know if you are interested. You did comment, so I am sure you have some interest. Let me know. I was in negotiations, however, they fell through.
Thanks

B


this is what you said...when I said wait for the auction to run its course essentially THEN you did ask me what you thought it would sell for..


I assumed when you asked 'if I was interested' that it meant for me to make an offer...I apologize if I misunderstood... ..

[bobbyw8469]

recently had one of the head graders from SGC look at the card and he told me they would bump it up a half point and assign it a 3.5.

May I ask who the person was that said this?

[PolarBear]

Originally Posted by filmmaker

I didnt ask you what you would pay for it?
I simply asked "what you thought it would sell for"

I think it will sell for $4,000.

[ullmandds]

i see it selling for around 4500-5K myself

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

i see it selling for around 4500-5K myself

if I was the seller I would want to know what people think it would go for publically to help strengthen a private deal as leverage...

but you thinking what it may go for isn't for sure what you would be offering....

[filmmaker]

11/03/2015 $6,750 usd

[gemmint77]

Nice card!!

[scottglevy]

Been away for a few days so just checked in and I guess the card is no longer for sale? I was interested but now I'm just confused ??

[Sean]

I guess this auction is over... or at least it's on hold pending the outcome of the PWCC auction on ebay this afternoon.

[HRBAKER]

At a minimum, there's some entertainment value here.
After all, that's what a filmmaker is after, right?

[bobbyw8469]

The oddest auction ever. I shall follow suite however. I have a 1952 Bowman Mantle SGC "A". it looks like a '7'. I shall start the bidding at $100,000.

[PolarBear]

Did it hit $1500 yet?

[caramelcard]

This guy came on here and made a mockery of the board...twice. We don't know his name so we'll be unable to avoid him in the future.

Very frustrating.

Rob

[Jeff_cvc]

Originally Posted by PolarBear

Did it hit $1500 yet?

If we went by the last two posts by the OP, it dropped $250 from the 2nd to the 3rd. Assuming he would continue dropping $250 a day until we had a winner, it would reach $1500 on November 24th. I suggest checking back in at this time to collect your OM Cobb.