1887-1890 Old Judge NEW QUESTION

[Joshchisox08]

New question.

My research on this set has hit a weird fork in the road. I've not seen ANY consistent checklist for this set.

http://www.tradingcarddb.com/ViewAll...2)?PageIndex=1

This checklist suggests that there are multiple cards for certain players that the above checklist site does NOT have.

http://www.teamsets4u.com/checklist/1800s/1887n172.html


Which if either of these are accurate? The second one also has teams that aren't listed on the first checklist. Which is the correct one ?

[shernan30]

Originally Posted by Joshchisox08

New question.
My research on this set has hit a weird fork in the road. I've not seen ANY consistent checklist for this set.

There is a lot when it comes to a complete checklist. The Old Judge book has a pretty good list. You can also check out my website for a complete list of Columbus Solons and other players who played in Columbus. I know there is a second pose of Billy Barnie which I just learned of about a week ago not listed on my site yet. Also, with each pose there could be variations depending on what years they were issued. A complete set is easily over 3000 cards if I'm not mistaken. Some board members may be able to give you a more accurate number of total cards in the set.

Columbus Ohio Old Judge Players

[Joshchisox08]

Thanks Steve !!!

Those two websites must be useless then lol. 576 was the total they said. Maybe that is without the variations.

I think I may just wind up getting the book !!!

Great website btw !!!