1950 R423 and 1950 gum ball charms

[GoldenAge50s]

not a giants uniform on the charm marshall 42-49

Neckline looks the same to me, what's wrong w/ it?

Here's my original thread w/ other charms & ID's including Sid Gordon (For gr8beldini)

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...ghlight=charms

[sflayank]

2 stripes around the collar...ny giants only 1
fred y has them all right...but hes calling this one wally westlake....westlake was righty...could be a follow thru photo
but cant find a match....r423 bond exhibits

[GoldenAge50s]

I appreciate all the help & information so far, but would really like to hear more opinions & ideas as to who this player may be.

I'm certain that while he probably isn't a "big star" he is a player that we most likely know & have heard of. None of the known charms are of real obscure players w/ the lesser known names such as Ennis, Schmitz and Sid Gordon being good players in the late '40's & early '50's during the issue of these charms.

I know we can nail this guy down if we get a few more eyes to look at this thread & a few more suggestions.

[sflayank]

a young duke snider is still very possible

[GoldenAge50s]

Young or old, Duke's ears are waaaaay different for sure, (see Post 5) and I'm NOT "ear ID" proficient.

Keep the comments coming so we can figure this guy out for certain.

[sflayank]

Check out lot i just listed under bst

[glynparson]

Larry put up a terrific lot on the bst. Awesome lot of color variations etc.