Real or Fake ... E90 Matty

[ceast]

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-E90-1-A...vip=true&rt=nc

[trdcrdkid]

Looks fake, especially next to this graded one:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-11-Amer...1/191295923093

[Paul S]

I've owned quite a few busted-up E90-1s. I've never seen that sort of chipping/paper loss around the borders like that before. Underneath the surface of the card the stock should be white, not that dark "cardboard gray".

[irishdenny]

Definitely a Fake!

As Paul has mentioned, the Paper is All wrong!
The Colors & gloss on the card also show that the card is a repo...

I also don't believe that the repo has been trimmed,
& wit the corners bein so sharp iN its present condition
iS also a Complete stretch of possibilities!

Here is One of my MaTTy's!

[ceast]

Followup question...so what is the best course of action to get out of paying for it? Or am I stuck with a $90 learning lesson?

[Joshchisox08]

I'm no expert on the subject as luckily I'm not smart enough to detect fake cards but I buy graded cards =) If you haven't paid for it just tell him that you believe it to be a reprint and aren't comfortable and if he tells you you have to tell him you'll file a claim with eBay for miss-labeling his item in a fraud/esc manner.